The Taxpayer’s Right to Privacy in Context of the Article 48 of the Polish Act on National Revenue Administration (KAS)

Authors

Keywords:

tax, taxpayer, Taxpayer’s rights, privacy, tax administration

Abstract

The considerations concern a problem that is rarely raised on the basis of tax issues, namely the taxpayer's right to privacy. They are carried out in the context of one of the legal regulations which has a significant impact on the development of the protection of the privacy of the taxpayer. It should be noted that the changes to tax rules introduced in the last decade clearly indicate that the tax legislator shifts the boundaries of the taxpayer's inviolable privacy sphere. In the first part, an theoretical understanding of the notion of taxpayer's privacy will be considered. The considerations will serve as a starting point for the second part of the discussion, which focuses on the taxpayer’s right to privacy by exploring normative basis for protection of taxpayer’s privacy. The following third part addresses how specific tax rules affect the development of the protected and inviolable sphere of the privacy of a taxpayer. The study carried out leads inter alia to conclusion that the current status of the taxpayer's right to privacy seems questionable and not spotted enough, as the legislator invasions the private sphere of taxpayers using a number of tools to this end. The author therefore argues that the strengthening and updating the taxpayer's right to privacy protection is necessary.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Chrabonszczewski M.: Prywatność. Teoria i praktyka [Privacy. Theory and practice], Warszawa: Aspra, 2012.

DeCew, J.W.: The Scope of Privacy in Law and Ethics, Law and Philoshopia, vol. 5, No 2, 1986.

Dopierała, R.: Prywatność w perspektywie zmiany społecznej [Privacy in the perspective of social change], Nomos: Kraków 2013.

Drywa, A.: In Search for Useful Understanding the term „Privacy” in Tax Matters, Financial Law Review, No 27(3), 2022.

Drywa, A.: Taxpayer’s Right to Privacy?, Intertax, vol. 50, Issue 1, 2022.

Ferenc-Kopeć, D.: Definicje legalne w dokumentach międzynarodowej ochrony praw człowieka [Legal definitions in international human rights instruments] (in:) Król, M., Bartczak, A., Zalewska, M. (eds.): Integracja zewnętrzna i wewnętrzna nauk prawnych [External and internal integration of the legal sciences], part 2, Łódź: Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Łódzkiego [Łódź University Press], 2014.

Jagielski M.: Podmioty w prawach człowieka [Subjects in human rights ] (in:) Bielska-Brodziak A. (ed.): O czym mówią prawnicy, mówiąc o podmiotowości [What lawyers are talking about when they talk about subjectivity], Katowice: Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Śląskiego [Śląsk University Press], 2015.

Gavison, R.: Privacy and the Limits of Law, The Yale Law Journal, vol. 89, No 3, 1980.

Gomułowicz A.: Podatnik a państwo [Taxpayer vs. state ] (in:) H. Dzwonkowski (ed.): Procedury podatkowe – gwarancje procesowe czy instrument fiskalizmu? [Tax procedures - procedural guarantees or an instrument of fiscalism?], Warszawa: C. H. Beck, 2005.

Henkin, L.: Privacy and Authonomy, Columbia Law Review, vol. 74, No 8, 1974.

Janion, M.: Odnawianie znaczeń [Redefinition of Meanings], Kraków: Wydawnictwo Literackie, 1980.

Kahn, J.: Privacy as a Legal Principle of Identity Maintenance, Seton Hall Law Review, vol. 33, 2003.

Leith, P.: The Socio-Legal Context of Privacy, International Journal of Law in Context, No 2, 2006.

Motyka, K.: Spory wokół prawa do prywatności – na przykładzie Stanów Zjednoczonych [Disputes over the right to privacy - an example from the United States] (in) Motyka, K. (ed.): Prawo do prywatności. Aspekty prawne i psychologiczne [Right to Privacy. Legal and psychological aspects], Lublin: Morpol, 2001.

Nykiel W., Sęk M.: Karta praw podatnika. Nowy instrument ochrony praw polskiego podatnika [Taxpayer Bill of Rights. A new instrument to protect the rights of the Polish taxpayer], Łódź: Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Łódzkiego [Łódź University Press], 2022.

Parent, W.A.: A New Definition of Privacy for the Law, Law and Philosophy, No 2, 1983.

Parent, W.A.: Recent Work on the Concept of Privacy, American Philosophical Quaterly, vol 20, No 4., 1983.

Posner, R.A.: Privacy, Surveillance, and Law, Chicago: The University of Chicago Law Review, No 75, 2008.

Post, R.C.: Three Concepts of Privacy, The Georgetown Law Journal, No 89 (6), 2001.

Safjan, M.: Wyzwania dla państwa prawa [Challenges for the state under the rule of law], Warszawa: Wolters Kluwer, 2007.

Sakowicz, A.: Prywatność jako samoistne dobro prawne (per se) [Privacy as a self-contained legal good], Państwo i Prawo, No 1, 2006.

Solove, D.J.: Understanding Privacy, Cambridge-London 2009.

Solove, D.J.: Conceptualizing Privacy, California Law Review, vol 1087, No 90, 2002.

Szyszkowski, W.: Prywatność w Stanach Zjednoczonych, jej ochrona i realizacja (in) Góralski, W. (ed.): Prawa i wolności obywatelskie w państwach kapitalistycznych, Warszawa 1979.

Thomson, J.J.: The Right to Privacy, Philosophy & Public Affairs, Vol. 4, No 4, 1975.

Warren, S.D., Brandeis, L.D.: The Right to Privacy, Harvard Law Review, vol. 4, No 5, reprinted: Ex Libris Leopold Classic Library, 1890.

Westin, A.F.: Privacy and Freedom, New York 1967.

Zaleski, Z.: Prawa do prywatności - aspekty psychologiczne (in:) Motyka, K. (ed.): Prawo do prywatności. Aspekty prawne i psychologiczne [Right to Privacy. Legal and psychological aspects], Lublin: Morpol, 2001.

Legal Acts

Act of 10 December 1948, Universal Declaration of Human Rights.

Act of 1950 the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (Journal of Laws of 1993, No 61, item 284).

Act of 1966 the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, (Journal of Laws of 1977, No 38, item 167).

Act of 7 December 2000, the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union (Journal of Laws EC 202 of 2016, p. 389).

Act of 20 May 1971, Code of Conduct on offenses (Journal of Laws of 2022, item 2151).

Act of 28 September 1991, Fiscal Control (Journal of Laws of 2016, item 720), repealed.

Act of 29 August 1997 Banking Law (Journal of Laws of 2021, item 2439).

Act of 27 August 2009, Customs Service (Journal of Laws of 2016, item 1799), repealed.

Act of 16 November 2016 on National Revenue Administration (Journal of Laws of 2016, item 1948).

Act of 29 October 2021, On amending the Law on Personal Income Tax, the Law on Corporate Income Tax and certain other laws (Journal of Laws of 2021, item 2105).

Court rulings

Constitutional Tribunal (TK) judgment of 24 June 1997, K 21/96.

Constitutional Tribunal (TK) judgment of 8 June 1999, SK 12/98.

Constitutional Tribunal (TK) judgment of 20 November 2002, K 41/02.

Constitutional Tribunal (TK) judgment of 18 October 2011, SK 2/10.

Constitutional Tribunal (TK) judgment of 12 January 2012, Kp 10/09.

Constitutional Tribunal (TK) judgment of 15 May 2012, P 11/10.

Constitutional Tribunal (TK) judgment of 31 January 2013, K 14/11.

Constitutional Tribunal (TK) judgment of 11 February 2014 , P 24/12.

Constitutional Tribunal (TK) judgment of 19 July 2018, SK 19/17.

European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) judgment of 18 December.1996, Loizidou v. Turkey, 15318/89.

Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) judgment of 21 September. 1989, Hoechst, C-46/87 and 227/88.

Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) judgment of 22 October. 2002, Roquette Frères, C-94/00, Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) judgment of 17 November. 2005, Minoan Lines, C-121/04 P.

Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) judgment of 25 November. 2014, Orange v Commission, T-401/13.

Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) judgment of 16 July. 2020, Facebook Ireland and Schrems, C-311/18.

Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) judgment of 6 October. 2020, Joined Cases C-245/19 and C-246/19.

The Supreme Court (SN) judgement of 3 October. 2019, I CSK 294/18.

Provincial Administrative Court (WSA) in Gorzów Wielkopolski judgment of 16 September. 2020, I Sa/Go 212/20.

Downloads

Published

23.10.2023

How to Cite

Drywa, A. (2023). The Taxpayer’s Right to Privacy in Context of the Article 48 of the Polish Act on National Revenue Administration (KAS). Financial Law Review, (31(3), 55–80. Retrieved from https://czasopisma.bg.ug.edu.pl/index.php/flr/article/view/9993

Issue

Section

Articles