Academic Scientific JournalsIncompletely Theorized Agreements and their Significance for Tax Law-Making
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.4467/22996834FLR.20.010.12432Keywords:
incompletely theorized agreements, democratic discourse, law, financial law, application of financial law, financial law-makingAbstract
This contribution introduces the idea of incompletely theorized agreements conceived by American legal theorist Cass R. Sunstein to the doctrine of tax law. The main aim of the contribution is to describe the content and nature of the idea in by presenting the ways in which it may be seen as coherent with empirical reality and how to assess its connection to it. The paper also draws several conclusions that can be made by juxtaposing the idea with the process and issues of tax law-making in divided society with examples drawn from Polish practice. What follows is the prescription to keep the discussion concerning tax law amendments as disconnected from political practice in divided society as possible, in order to maintain tax law quality and efficiency. It should be practically oriented and focusing on outcomes of projected legislative actions that are possible to predict. The methods used in the article are mainly description, discussion compiling and reshaping of theoretical ideas, rhetorical justification and grounding of drawn conclusions.
Downloads
References
Alexander, L.: Incomplete Theorizing: A Review Essay of Cass R. Sunstein's Legal Reasoning and Political Conflict, Notre Dame Law Review, vol. 72 (531), 1997.
Bathaee, Y.: Incompletely Theorized Agreements: An Unworkable Theory of Judicial Modesty, Fordham Urban Law Journal, vol. 34 (5), 2007.
Berlin, I.: The Hedgehog and the Fox, New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 2013.
Brzeziński, B.: Theoretical Perspective in: Nykiel, W., Sęk, M.: Tax Legislation. Standards, Trends and Challenges, Warsaw: Wolters a Kluwer Business, 2015.
Drywa, A.: The Quality of the Tax Law as a Factor Shaping the Taxpayer’s Legal Position, in: Radvan, M., Gliniecka, J., Sowiński, T., Mrkývka, P. (eds.): The Financial Law Towards Challenges of the XXI Century, Brno: Publications of the Masaryk University, 2017.
Duxbury, N. Ambition and Adjudication, The University of Toronto Law Journal, vol. 47 (1), 1997.
Dworkin, R.: In Praise of Theory, Arizona State Law Journal, vol. 29 (2), 1997.
Dworkin, R.: Justice for Hedgehogs, Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 2011.
George, R., P.: Law, Democracy and Moral Disagreement, Harvard Law Review, vol. 110 (7), 1997.
Gomułowicz, A.: Podatki a etyka [Taxation and Ethics], Warsaw: Wolters Kluwer Poland, 2013.
Goodman, N.: On Starmaking, in: McCormick, P. J. (ed.), Starmaking. Realism, Anti-Realism, Irrealism, Massachusetts: Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 1996.
Goodman, N.: Ways of Worldmaking, Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing Company, 1978.
Grant Thornton Barometer on Stability of Legal Environment in Polish Economy, 2019 Edition, Available at: http://barometrprawa.pl/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/GrantThornton_barometr_prawa_022019.pdf, accessed: 9th June 2020.
Gribnau, J. L. M.,: Equality, Consistency and Impartiality in Tax Legislation, in: Legal Protection Against Discriminatory Tax Legislation. The Struggle for Equality in European Tax Law, The Hague: Kluwer Law International, 2003.
Marzęcki, R., Konstruowanie wzajemnych relacji jako element stylu uprawiania polityki PO i PiS [Building mutual relations as an element of the political style of the Civic Platform (PO) and Law and Justice (PiS) parties], Środkowoeuropejskie Studia Polityczne [Central European Political Studies], vol. 10 (2), 2012. Available at: https://pressto.amu.edu.pl/index.php/ssp/article/download/10484/10023, accessed: 9th June 2020.
Mrkývka, P., Czudek, D.: Stability and Stabilization of Financial Law, in: Radvan, M., Gliniecka, J., Sowiński, T., Mrkývka, P. (eds.): The Financial Law Towards Challenges of the XXI Century, Brno: Publications of the Masaryk University, 2017.
Obuchowski, S.: On Some Assumptions in the Dogmatic Study of Tax Law, Financial Law Review, vol. 3 (1), 2018. Available at: http://www.ejournals.eu/pliki/art/12107/pl, accessed: 9th June 2020.
Obuchowski, S.: Pojęcie zasad prawa w świetle idei pojęć co do istoty kwestionowalnych [The Notion of the 'Principles of Law' in the Light of the Idea of 'Essentially Contested Concepts'], Ruch Prawniczy, Ekonomiczny i Socjologiczny [Journal of Law, Economics and Sociology] vol. 79 (4), 2017. Available at: https://pressto.amu.edu.pl/index.php/rpeis/article/view/11848/11698.
Ostrowski, K.: Prawo finansowe. Zarys ogólny [Financial Law. General Outline], Warsaw: Państwowe Wydawnictwo Naukowe PWN [Polish Scientific Publishers PWN], 1970.
Piotrowska-Marczak, K.: Finance and Financial Law. Relationships and Dependencies, in: Mrkývka, P., Gliniecka, J., Tomášková, E., Juchniewicz, E., Sowiński, T., Radvan, M. (eds.): The Challenges of Local Government Financing in the Light of European Union Regional Policy, Brno: Publications of the Masaryk University, 2018.
Raymond, J. C.: The Methodology of the Humanities, College English, vol. 48 (8), 1982.
Rubin, L.: Legal Reasoning, Legal Process and the Judiciary as an Institution, California Law Review, vol. 85 (1), 1997.
Ruger, J., P.: Health, Health Care, and Incompletely Theorized Agreements: A Normative Theory of Health Policy Decision Making, Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, Vol. 32, No. 1, 2007.
Saphiro, S., J.: Fear of Theory, The University of Chicago Law Review, vol. 64 (1), 1997.
Scholz, J, T.: Trust, Taxes and Compliance, in: Braithwaite, V., Levi, M.: Trust and Governance, New York: Russel Sage Foundation, 1998.
Schroeder, D.: Human Rights and Human Dignity. An Appeal to Separate the Conjoined Twins, Human Rights and Human Dignity, Ethical Theory and Moral Practice, vol. 15 (3), 2012.
Stone, A.: Incomplete Theorizing in the High Court, Federal Law Review, vol. 26 (1), 1998.
Sunstein, C. R., Commentary: Incompletely Theorized Agreements, Harvard Law Review, vol. 108 (7), 1995.
Sunstein, C. R.: Designing Democracy: What Constitutions Do, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2001.
Sunstein, C. R.: Political Conclict and Legal Agreement, Tanner Lectures on Human Values, available at: https://tannerlectures.utah.edu/_documents/a-to-z/s/Sunstein96.pdf, accessed: 9th June 2020.
Sunstein, C., R.: Legal Reasoning and Political Conflict, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1996.
Verma, N.: Urban Design. An Incompletely Theorized Project, in: Banerjee, T., Loukaitou-Sideris A. (eds.): Companion to Urban Design, New York: Routlege, 2011.
Legal Acts:
Act of 11th March, 2004 on Goods and Services Tax (consolidated Text Journal of Laws 2020, item 106 as amended).
Act of 23rd October, 2018 on the Solidarity Support Fund for the Disabled (Journal of Laws 2018, item 2192, as amended).
Act of 8th January 1993 on Goods and Services Tax and Excise Tax (Journal of Laws 1993, no. 11, item 50, as amended).
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Financial Law Review is an open access journal which means that all the articles published are freely available without charge to the reader or his/her institution.
The articles published in Financial Law Review are available under a licence Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0)
The Author furnishes a non-exclusive and free-of-charge license to use the his Work without territorial limitations and for an unlimited period.
Archiving policy
All texts from the journal Financial Law Review are published in electronic version. We strive to archive texts in various databases. Archival issues are also available on the platform of the Academic Scientific Journals: https://czasopisma.bg.ug.edu.pl/index.php/flr/index
Moreover articles published in the journal are archived at the Repository of the University of Gdansk.
