Academic Scientific JournalsExperience of implementing decommunization laws in Eastern Ukraine: a Kharkiv case
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.26881/jpgs.2020.3.06Keywords:
decommunization, Ukraine, Kharkiv, politics of memoryAbstract
The article deals with an instrumental use of the national legislation by the local authorities in Kharkiv, the second-largest city in Ukraine and shows how the shortcomings in the national legislation on the politics of memory can be used by the local political elites of “borderland city” in an attempt to raise the rating and/or to mobilize the electorate before the elections. Consequently, several interviews with local experts and activists were conducted in 2019, and qualitative data analysis was made for the transcribed texts as well as a short review of other papers on the subject. Also, the article shows how the local court can accelerate the process of depriving a historical building of the status of an architectural monument using decommunization laws. The study confirms the existence of serious polarization in Ukrainian society and the superficial nature of decommunization (started in 2015), which stimulates the deepening of such polarization.
Downloads
References
Balacuk I., 2019, Zelensky: Bandera buv by v šoci, skil’ky vulyc’ z jogo im’ âm (Eng. Zelensky: Bandera would be shocked how many streets are named after him), Ukraïnc’ka Pravda, 10.10.2019, https://www.pravda.com.ua/news/2019/10/10/7228731/ (accessed 15 April 2020).
Barkov S., 2019, Aktivisty sorvali tablički s imenem Žukova s domov pereimenovannogo prospekta (Eng. Activists ripped the signs with Zhukov’s name off the houses of the renamed avenue), Objectiv, https://www.objectiv.tv/objectively/2019/06/26/aktivisty-sorvali-tablichki-s-imenem-zhukova-s-domov-pereimenovannogo-prospekta/(accessed 15 April 2020).
Borisova T. (ed.), 1977, Istoriko-revolûcionnye pamâtniki Har’kovŝiny (Eng. Historical and Revolutionary Monuments in Kharkiv region), Kharkiv, Prapor.
Commotion and Controversial Petitions on Victory Day in Kharkiv, 2019, Kharkiv Observer, http://kharkivobserver.com/commotion-and-controversial-petitions-on-victoryday-in-kharkiv/ (accessed 15 April 2020).
Gaidai O., Sklokina I., Kasianov G. (eds.), 2018, Politika i pam ‘ât’. Dnipro – Zaporižžâ – Odesa – Harkiv. Vid 1990-h dos’ogodni (Eng. Politics and Memory. Dnipro – Zaporizhzhya – Odesa – Kharkiv. From 1990s till today), FOP Shumylovych, Lviv.
Gnatiuk O., 2018, The renaming of streets in post-revolutionary Ukraine: regional strategies to construct a new national identity, AUC Geographica, 53(2), 119–136. doi: 10.14712/23361980.2018.13.
Golikov O., 2020, Pereimenovaniâ i dekommunizaciâ poukrainski: makropolitiki, istoričeskaya pamât’ i riski mediatizacii (keis Harkova) (Eng. (Re-)naming and decommunization in Ukrainian: macropolicies, historical memory and the risks of mediatization (Kharkiv case)), Ideology and Politics, 1(15), 3–62.
Grytsenko O., 2019, Dekomunizatsiâ v Ukraїni âk deržavna politika i socio-kul’turne âvyshche (Eng. Decommunization in Ukraine as a public policy and as a cultural phenomenon), Instytut polityčnyh i etno-nacional ‘nyh doslidžen’ im. I.F. Kurasa NAN Ukraїni, Kyїv.
Gubkina I., 2020, Losing My Religion: On Postwar Soviet Architecture in Contemporary Ukraine, Obieg, 14, https://obieg.u-jazdowski.pl/en/numery/euphoria-fatigue/losing-my-religion (accessed 15 April 2020).
Har’kovskij Enciklopedičeskij Slovar’, 2014 (Eng. Kharkiv encyclopedic dictionary), NTU KhPI, Kharkiv, http://repository.kpi.kharkov.ua/handle/KhPI-Press/4290 (accessed 15 April 2020).
Iniciativa perejmenuvannâ prospektu Petra Grigorenka u Harkovi viklikaê serjozne zanepokoênnia (Eng. The initiative to rename Petro Grigorenko Avenue in Kharkiv is a matter of serious concern), 2020, Ukraïns’kij institut nacional’noï pam’âtì, https://uinp.gov.ua/pres-centr/novyny/iniciatyva-pereymenuvannya-prospektu-petra-grygorenka-uharkovi-vyklykaye-seryozne-zanepokoyennya (accessed 15 April 2020).
Ishchenko V., 2016, The Ukrainian Left during and after the Maidan Protests, https://www.academia.edu/20445056/ The_Ukrainian_Left_during_and_after_the_Maidan_Protests (accessed 15 April 2020).
Kalita N., 2019, Kmitivskij muzej radâns’kogo mistectva ta Ievheniia Molyar (Eng. Kmytiv Soviet Art Muzeum and Ievheniia Molyar) https://supportyourart.com/ridnykraj/ kmpmmolyar, (accessed 15 April 2020).
Kasianov G., 2016, Istoričeskaâ politika i „memorial’ nye” zakony v Ukraine: načalo XXI veka (Eng. Historical policy and memory laws in Ukraine: early XXIst century), Istoricheskaya ekspertiza, 2, 28–57.
Kasianov G., 2018, Past Continuous: Istorična politika 1980- 2000 Ukraїna ta susidi (Eng. Past Continuous: Historical Policy 1980–2000: Ukraine and its Neighbours), Laurus, Kyiv.
Kozachenko I., 2019, Fighting for the Soviet Union 2.0: Digital nostalgia and national belonging in the context of the Ukrainian crisis, Communist and Post-Communist Studies, 52(1), 1–10. doi: 10.1016/j.postcomstud.2019.01.001
Kravcenko A., 2012, Tajny tvorčestva Mihaila Ovsânkina (Eng. Mysteries of Mikhail Ovsyankin’s work), Objectiv, http://archive.objectiv.tv/260512/70546.html (accessed 15 April 2020).
Kudelko S. (ed.), 2011, Har’kov: spravočnik po nazvaniâm: 7000 ulic, ploŝadej, skverov, rajonov (Eng. Kharkov: directory of names: 7000 streets, squares, parks, districts.), Saga, Kharkiv.
Kulyk V., 2017, Komu v Ukraїni potribni reformi (Eng. Who needs reforms in Ukraine), Dzerkalo Tižnâ, 13(1102), https://zn.ua/ukr/SOCIUM/komu-v-ukrayini-potribni-reformi-239002_.html (accessed 15 April 2020).
Kutsenko D., 2018, Some Aspects of Identity Politics of Kharkiv Local Authorities After 2013, Polish Political Science Review – Polski Przegląd Politologiczny, 6(1), 68–81. doi: 10.2478/ppsr-2018-000.
Kuzio T., 2015, Rise and Fall of the Party of Regions Political Machine, Problems of Post-Communism, 62(3), 174–186. doi: 10.1080/10758216.2015.1020127.
Lashenko E., 2019, Skandal s pamâtnikom Žukovu: Zelensky dal sovet Kernesu (Eng. The Zhukov monument scandal: Zelensky gave advice to Kernes), Liga.novosti, https://news.liga.net/politics/news/zelenskiy-sovetuet-kernesu-statarbitrom-dekommunizatsii, (accessed 15 April 2020).
Levin K., 2016, Interaktivna karta dekomunizaciї harkivs’koї toponimiki (Eng. Interactive map of the decommunization of Kharkiv toponymy), Allkharkov.ua, https://allkharkov.ua/news/state/nteraktivna-karta-dekomynzac-harkvskotoponmki.html (accessed 15 April 2020).
Minakov M., 2019, Mihailo Minakov pro vibori, populizm i ukraїns’kih intellektualiv (Eng. Mykhailo Minakov on elections, populism and Ukrainian intellectuals), https://commons.com.ua/uk/intervyu-z-mihajlom-minakovim/(accessed 15 April 2020).
Miroshnichenko E., 2019, Pobeda na vyborah, demonstraciâ sily i istoričeskaâ spravedlivost’. Počemu Kernes prodolžaet „borot’sâ” za Žukova (Eng. Election victory, show of force and historical justice. Why does Kernes keep “fighting” for Zhukov), https://www.057.ua/news/2674087/pobedana-vyborah-demonstracia-sily-i-istoriceskaa-spravedlivost-pocemu-kernes-prodolzaet-borotsa-za-zukova, (accessed 15 April 2020).
Mis’krada fal’ syfikuê rezul’taty golosuvannâ po perejmenuvannû prospekta imeni generala Grigorenka (Eng. The City Council falsifies the results of voting for the renaming of General Grigorenko Avenue), 2019, 2day, https://2day.kh.ua/verhom-na-zhukove-kernes-i-muraev-proletayutmimo-parlamenta (accessed 15 April 2020).
Nikiforov Y., 2017, Decommunized: Ukrainian Soviet Mosaics, Osnovy Publishing, Kyiv-Berlin.
Operaciâ “Zahoplennâ”: âk blogeri z „Demsokiri” vzâli pid kontrol’ radu gromads’kogo kontrolû NABU (Eng. Operation Capture: How Demsokyra Bloggers Take Control of NABU Public Oversight Board), 2019, LB.ua, https://ukr.lb.ua/news/2019/06/11/429269_operatsiya_zahoplennya_yak_blogeri_z.html (accessed 15 April 2020).
“Otraženie-Viddzerkalennâ” 03.04.2016 – Tahtaulova, Gubkina (Eng. “Reflection” 03.04.2016 – Takhtaulova, Gubkina), https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MxRwM7c7ETM, (accessed 15 April 2020).
Prospektu maršala Žukova snova vernuli ego istoričeskoe nazvanie (Eng. Marshal Zhukov Avenue has been given its historical name again), 2020, Har’kovskie Izvestiâ, 26.2.2020, http://izvestia.kharkov.ua/on-line/gorod/1300990.html (accessed 15 April 2020).
Prospektu maršala Žukova v Har’kove byt’ (Eng. Marshal Zhukov Avenue in Kharkiv to be), 2016, Har’kovskie Izvestiâ, https://izvestia.kharkov.ua/on-line/gorod/1220651.html (accessed 15 April 2020).
Riabchuk M., 2016, Dekomunizaciâ chy dekolonizaciâ? Ŝo pokazali politični diskusiї z privodu dekomunizacijnih zakoniv (Eng. Decommunization or decolonization? What did the discussions about decommunization laws show?), Naukovi zapiski Institutu političnih i etnonacionalnih doslidžen’ im. I.F. Kurasa NAN Ukraїni, 2, 104–117.
Rišennya No 82345242, 03.06.2019, (Decision No 82345242, 03.06.2019), 2019, Harkivs’kij Okružnyj Administrativnij Sud, https://youcontrol.com.ua/catalog/court-document/82345242/ (accessed 15 April 2020).
Rišennya ŝodo nazv ob’ektiv toponimiki maût’ pryjmatisâ vidpovidno do činnogo zakonodavstva (Eng. Decisions on the names of toponymic objects must be made in accordance with current legislation), 2019, KhOSA, https://kharkivoda.gov.ua/news/99234 (accessed 15 April 2020).
Serhiienko S., 2017, Istorična politika v Ukraїni (Eng. Historical policy in Ukraine), https://commons.com.ua/uk/istorichna-politika-v-ukrayini/ (accessed 15 April 2020).
Shekhovtsov A., 2020, Why Azov should not be designated a foreign terrorist organization, https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/blogs/ukrainealert/why-azov-should-not-bedesignated-a-foreign-terrorist-organization/ (accessed 15 April 2020).
Takhtaulova M., 2017, Harkivs’ka toponimika: etapy dekomunizaciї (Eng. Kharkiv toponymy: stages of decommunization), Misto: istoriâ, kul’tura, suspil ‘stvo, 2, 142–151.
Troubled Weekend: Mayors’ Party Congress and Statue Zhukov’s Toppling, 2019, Kharkiv Observer, https://kharkivobserver.com/troubled-weekend-mayors-party-congress-andstatue-zhukovs-toppling/ (accessed 15 April 2020).
U Harkovi včyteli prosili bat’kiv golosuvaty “za” Žukova (Eng. In Kharkiv, teachers asked parents to vote “for” Zhukov), 2020, 2day, https://2day.kh.ua/ua/u-kharkovi-vchiteliprosili-batkiv-golosuvati-za-zhukova (accessed 15 April 2020).
U Harkovi vidbudet’sâ prezentatsiâ pivnično-shidnogo mižrehional‘nogo viddilu Ukraїnskogo Institutu nacionalnoї pam’ âti (Eng. A presentation of the North-Eastern Interregional Department of the Ukrainian Institute of National Memory will take place in Kharkiv), 2019, Ukraïns’kij institut nacional’noï pam’âtì, https://uinp.gov.ua/pres-centr/novyny/u-harkovi-vidbudetsya-prezentaciya-pivnichnoshidnogo-mizhregionalnogo-viddilu-ukrayinskogo-instytutu-nacionalnoyi-pamyati (accessed 15 April 2020).
V AP otkazalis’ vozvraŝat prospektu imâ maršala Žukova (Eng. The AP refused to return the name of Marshal Zhukov to the Avenue), 2016, Har’kovskie Izvestiâ, 5.12.2016, https://izvestia.kharkov.ua/on-line/20/1228800.html (accessed 15 April 2020).
V Har’kove isčezli ulicy, nazvannye v čest organizatorov krasnogo terrora (Eng. Streets named after the organizers of the red terror have disappeared in Kharkiv), 2016, https://nakipelo.ua/udalit-zapis-v-harkove-ischezli-ulitsy-nazvannye-v-chest-organizatorov-krasnogo-terrora/ (accessed 15 April 2020).
Verhom na Žukove. Kernes i Muraev proletaût’ mimo parlamenta (Eng. Top on Zhukov. Kernes and Murayev are passed over by the parliament), 2019, 2day, https://2day.kh.ua/verhom-na-zhukove-kernes-i-muraev-proletayut-mimoparlamenta (accessed 15 April 2020).
Z Žukovim u Harkovi nemaê pravovoї koliziї: pam’ âtnik slid demontuvati (Eng. There is no legal conflict with Zhukov in Kharkiv: the monument should be dismantled), 2019, Ukraïns’kij institut nacional’noï pam’âtì, https://uinp.gov.ua/pres-centr/novyny/z-zhukovym-u-harkovi-nemayepravovoyi-koliziyi-pamyatnyk-slid-demontuvaty-instytut-nacionalnoyi-pamyati (accessed 15 April 2020).
Zaâva ŝodo rišennâ Harkivs’koї mis’koї radi perejmenuvati prospekt Petra Grigorenka (Eng. Statement on the decision of the Kharkiv City Council to rename Petro Grigorenko Avenue), 2020, Ukraïns’kij institut nacional’noï pam’âtì, https://uinp.gov.ua/pres-centr/novyny/zayava-shchodorishennya-harkivskoyi-miskoyi-rady-pereymenuvatyprospekt-petra-grygorenka (accessed 15 April 2020).
Zasidannâ Konsul’tativnoї radi pitan’ ohoroni kul’turnoї spadŝini pri Upravlìnnì kul’turi ì turizmu Harkìvs’koї oblasnoї deržavnoї admìnìstracìї 18.01.2019 (Eng. Meeting of the Advisory Council on Protection of Cultural Heritage at the Department of Culture and Tourism of the Kharkiv Regional State Administration 18.01.2019), 2019, Oblasnij komunalnij zaklad «Harkìvs’kij naukovo-metodičnij centrohoroni kul’turnoї spadŝini», http://www.spadschina.kh.ua/18.01.2019-засідання-консультативної-ради.html (accessed 15 April 2020).
Zakon Ukraїni pro zasudžennâ komunističnogo i nacionalsocialističnogo (nacists’kogo) totalitarnih režimiv v Ukraїni ta zaboronu їhn’oї simvoliki No 317-VIII (Eng. Law of Ukraine On the Condemnation of the Communist and National Socialist (Nazi) Regimes, and Prohibition of Propaganda of Their Symbols No 317-VIII), 2015, https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/317-19#Text (accessed 15 April 2020).
Zhurzhenko T., 2016, Memory wars in post-soviet Kharkiv [in:] D. Segert (ed.), Civic Education and Democratisation in the Eastern Partnership Countries, Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung, Bonn, 102–123.
Zub E., 2016, Eduard Zub. Toponimični zmini. Harkiv (Eng. Eduard Zub. Toponymical changes. Kharkiv), http://www.historians.in.ua/index.php/en/istoriya-i-pamyat-vazhkipitannya/1751-eduard-zub-toponimichni-zminy-kharkiv (accessed 15 April 2020).
