Propaganda and journalism (in the context on the Second Karabath War)

Authors

  • Oksana Kosiuk Lesya Ukrainka Volyn National University

Keywords:

Nagorno Karabakh, Propaganda, Ideology, Media, Armed Conflict, State, Information War

Abstract

Propaganda has always existed; it only changed its forms. In the early days of media it first flooded the pages of popular periodicals and later when the media improved and clearly outlined their boundaries on the basis of international standards it became in opposition to journalism and was legally circulated without obstacles exclusively in party and religious media. Therefore it is regarded in journalism as a negative manifestation of fake creativity and gross evidence of information imbalance. However, has this ambivalent phenomenon really disappeared “law abidingly” from leading mass media and consequently what effect has it had on public consciousness and national security of states which are in zones of military confrontation? We are answering the above mentioned and similar questions in the article through the example of the analysis of key mass media in Azerbaijan, Armenia, Russia and Ukraine. Mediation of the conflict in Nagorno Karabakh was purposefully chosen as the objective of scientific receptions but not the war in eastern Ukraine as it could be reasonable to expect with the aim to abstract ourselves from personal views and experiences and check objectively if there is any propaganda and how it works in the coverage of global military conflicts that directly or indirectly affect certain states. It was equally important to investigate whether the implementation of information standards contributes to settlement of intra-state and international confrontations. It has been found out that compliance with media norms is in inverse proportion to national interests. Finding a way out of these clear-cut situations opens up prospects for new research.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Azer Tag. (2021). Azerbajdzhanskoe gosudarstvennoe informacionnoe agentstvo. https:// azertag.az/ (po sostojaniju na 29 aprelja 2021).

Baghdasaryan, Laura & Barseghyan, Suzanna & Stepanyan Shoghik. (2019) Media consumption and information preferences in Аrmenia. Yerevan : “Region” Research Center, 6–7.

Hetq. (2020–2021). Zhurnalisty-rassledovateli. https://hetq.am/hy (po sostojaniju na dekabr’-fevral’ 2020–2021).

Horbyk, Roman & Prymachenko, Yana & Yurchuk Yuliya. (2019). Shared history in shattered spaces: mediatization of istorical scholarship in Ukraine and broader eastern Europe. Ідеологія і політика. 3(14): 129–148.

Kosiuk, Oksana. (2020). Transformation of modern military journalism. The role of technology in the socio-economic development of the post-quarantine world. Katowice : Publishing House of Katowice School of Technology, 54–65.

Law on Not Opening “A1+”. (2020). News Online http://www.yerevannights.com/NewsOnline/article.aspx?id=159 (as of 10 May 2021).

Siebert, Fred & Peterson, Theodore & Schramm, Wilbur. (1984). Four Theories of the Press: The Authoritarian, Libertarian, Social Responsibility, and Soviet Communist Concepts of What the Press Should Be and Do : University of Illinois Press.

Trend. (2021). Informacionnoe agentstvo. https://www.trend.az/ (po sostojaniju na 1 maja 2021).

Turan. (2021). Informacionnoe agentstvo. https://turan.az/ (po sostojaniju na 29 aprelja 2021).

A1+. (2021). YouTube-kanal. https://www.youtube.com/user/a1plusnews (po sostojaniju na dekabr’-fevral’ 2020–2021).

Aliev, Il’ham. (2021). Turcija i Azerbajdzhan rasshirili svoi vozmozhnosti v regione, nasha rol’, vlijanie vozrosli i budut rasti. Trend. https://www.trend.az/azerbaijan/politics/3418519. html (po sostojaniju na 3 maja 2021).

Aliev, Magerram. (2020).Uspehi, dostignutye segodnja v regione – rezul’tat sovmestnyh usilij Turcii i Azerbajdzhana. Trend. https://www.trend.az/azerbaijan/politics/3295994.html (po sostojaniju na 30 oktjabrja 2020).

Bedevjan, Asthik. (2020). Prokuratura proverjaet obnarodovannuju press-sekretarem prem’er-ministra informaciju o Mikajele Minasjane. Radio Azatutjun. https://rus.azatutyun. am/a/30583867.html (po sostojaniju na 29 aprelja 2020).

Bogatko, Julija. (2006). Jozef Gebbel’s (TM) kak papa massovyh kommunikacij https://www. sostav.ru/columns/eyes/2006/k53/ (stanom na 29 bereznja 2021).

Busel, V. T. (2005). Velykyj tlumachnyj slovnyk suchasnoji ukrajinsjkoji movy (z dod. i dopov.). https://slovnyk.me/dict/vts/%D0%BF%D1%80%D0%BE%D0%BF%D0%B0%D0%B3%D0%B0%D0%BD%D0%B4%D0%B0 (stanom na 5 kvitnja 2021 r.).

V Rosiji 25 ZMI ob’jednalysja u syndykat dlja “nezalezhnogho vysvitlennja problem”. https:// www.pravda.com.ua/news/2020/02/29/7242126/ (stanom na 29 ljutogho 2020).

Ghaber, Jevghenija. (2020). Kavkazjki branci. Dzerkalo tyzhnja. https://zn.ua/ukr/international/kavkazki-brantsi.html (stanom na 22 lystopada 2020).

Gumanitarnyj portal. (2020). Rejting stran po indeksu svobody pressy, ijun’, https://gtmarket.ru/ratings/worldwide-press-freedom-index (po sostojaniju na 9 maja 2021).

David Tonojan provel operativnoe soveshhanie. (2020). Hetq. https://hetq.am/ru/article/122065 (po sostojaniju na 28 sentjabrja 2020) Delaem chestnuju zhurnalistiku vmeste s vami. Novaja gazeta. https://novayagazeta.ru/articles/2021/03/06/ministr-prosveshcheniia-v-rossii-zakroiut-dostup-k-negativnoi-informatsii-cherez-shkolnyi-wi-fi (po sostojaniju na 16 marta 2021).

Dzho Bajden iskazil istoricheskuju pravdu o sobytijah 1915 goda – MID Azerbajdzhana. (2021). Turan. https://turan.az/ext/news/2021/4/free/politics_news/ru/3424.htm (po sostojaniju na 24 aprelja 2021).

Drachuk, Serghij. (2009) Cherez desjatj rokiv Virmenija zghaduje rozstril u parlamenti. Radio svoboda. https://www.radiosvoboda.org/a/1862724.html (stanom na 10 travnja 2021).

Zhelenyn, Aleksandr. (2017). Chy je v Rosiji “nezalezhni” ZMI, i navishho vony Putinu? https://lb.ua/world/2017/05/31/367791_li_rossii_nezavisimie_smi.html (stanom na 31 travnja 2017).

Zakon Ukrajiny Pro informaciju. Vidomosti Verkhovnoji Rady Ukrajiny (VVR), 1992, # 48, st. 650. https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/2657-12?find=1&text=%D0%BF%D1%80%D0%BE%D0%BF%D0%B0%D0%B3%D0%B0%D0%BD%D0%B4%D0%B0#w1_1 (stanom na 15 travnja 2021).

Kazarjan, Diana i Kazarjan, Ajk. (2020). Povrezhdennye doma i ranenye: situacija v Stepanakerte. Hetq. https://hetq.am/ru/article/121984 (po sostojaniju na 31 dekabrja 2020).

Kosjuk, Oksana. (2012). Teorija masovoji komunikaciji : navch. posib. Lucjk : VNU im. Lesi Ukrajinky, 84–86.

Kochneva, Natal’ja. (2020). Grjaznaja provokacija armjan v Jestonii – neizvestnyj polozhil svinye golovy k islamskomu centru. Trend. https://www.trend.az/azerbaijan/karabakh/3330835. html (po sostojaniju na 7 nojabrja 2020).

Kravchenko, Volodymyr. (2020). Cina myru. Dzerkalo tyzhnja. https://zn.ua/ukr/international/tsina-miru.html (stanom na 11 lystopada 2020).

Kryvavi storinky istoriji – Khodzhalynsjkyj ghenocyd. (2021). Derzhavnyj Centr Perekladu Azerbajdzhanu https://www.aztc.gov.az/ua/posts/id:1216 (stanom na 25 ljutogho 2025).

Lashhenko, Jevghenij. (2020). Virmenija, Rosija i Azerbajdzhan domovylysja pro prypynennja vijny v Naghirnomu Karabakhu. Dzerkalo tyzhnja. https://zn.ua/ukr/WORLD/virmenija-rosija-i-azerbajdzhan-domovilisja-pro-pripinennja-vijni-v-nahirnomu-karabasi.html (stanom na 20 lystopada 2020).

Lidery stran ES obsudjat sankcii protiv Rossii v chetverg. (2017). Trend. https://www.trend. az/world/2834375.html (po sostojaniju na 12 dekabrja 2017).

Madatjan, Marine. (2013). Mezhdu Majdanom i evropejskoj roskosh’ju. Hetq. https://hetq. am/ru/article/54986 (po sostojaniju na 4 dekabrja 2013).

Mamuljan, Araks. (2020). Advokaty predstavili soobshhenie o gosudarstvennoj izmene. Hetq. https://hetq.am/ru/article/125682 (po sostojaniju na 22 dekabrja 2020).

Martirosjan, Marine. (2020). Paket mer po okazaniju pomoshhi armjanam Livana budet gotov do 1 sentjabrja. Hetq https://hetq.am/ru/article/120716 (po sostojaniju na 20 avgusta 2021).

Mehman, Asif. (2020). Vojna pokazala istinnoe lico Pashinjana. Trend. https://www.trend.az/ azerbaijan/politics/3326083.html (po sostojaniju na 30 oktjabrja 2020).

Ministr prosveshhenija: v Rossii zakrojut dostup k “negativnoj informacii” cherez shkol’nyj Wi-Fi. Novaja gazeta. https://novayagazeta.ru/articles/2021/03/06/ministr-prosveshcheniia-v-rossii-zakroiut-dostup-k-negativnoi-informatsii-cherez-shkolnyi-wi-fi (po sostojaniju na 6 marta 2021).

Minakov, Mykhajlo & Zasse, Gvendolin & Isachenko, Darija. (2019). Secesionizm u Jevropi. Ideologhija i polityka. 1(12): 4–10.

Montenegrinskoe izdanie opublikovalo stat’ju o godovshhine genocida azerbajdzhancev. (2021). Azer Tag. https://azertag.az/ru/xeber/Montenegrinskoe_izdanie_opublikovalo_statyu_o_ godovshchine_genocida_azerbaidzhancev-1745511 (po sostojaniju na 29 aprelja 2021) .

Ob#javlenie o nastrojke nekotoryh sajtov. (2020). Sluzhba nacional’noj bezopasnosti respubliki Armenija. https://www.sns.am/hy/ (po sostojaniju na 28 dekabrja 2020).

Pamjat’ krovi. Rubrika. (2021). Azer Tag. https://azertag.az/ru/bolme/bloody_memory (po sostojaniju na 29 aprelja 2021).

Pashinjan, Nikola. (2020). Pozdravitel’noe poslanie po sluchaju Novogo goda i Rozhdestva. Hetq. https://hetq.am/ru/article/125983 (po sostojaniju na 31 dekabrja 2020).

Pashynjan protiv voennyh. Glavnoe o krizise. Novaja gazeta. https://novayagazeta.ru/articles/2021/02/25/89379-pashinyan-protiv-voennyh-glavnoe-o-krizise (po sostojaniju na 25 fevralja 2021).

Petrovskaja, Irina. (2021). Na podvig otchizna zovet https://novayagazeta.ru/articles/2021/02/25/89376-na-podvig-otchizna-zovet-bolshie-sbornye-kont - serty-na-tv-kak-akt-patrioticheskogo-vospitaniya# (po sostojaniju na 25 fevralja 2021).

Pochepcov, Georgij. (2006). Teorija kommunikacii. M. : Refl-buk. K. : “Vakler”, 556–559.

Prezidentu pishut: Vasha reshitel’naja, mudraja i smelaja politika vedet azerbajdzhanskij narod v uspeshnoe budushhee i k blestjashhej pobede. (2020). Trend. https://www.trend.az/ azerbaijan/politics/3313368.html (po sostojaniju na 9 oktjabrja 2020).

Prezidenty Turcii i Francii vpervye za polgoda provedut prjamye peregovory. (2021). Trend. https://www.trend.az/world/turkey/3388682.html (po sostojaniju na 2 marta 2021).

Protivniku udalos’ vojti v selo Staryj Tahlar i priblizit’sja k selu Hcaberd. (2020). Hetq. https:// hetq.am/ru/article/125347 (po sostojaniju na 13 dekabrja 2021).

Rezuljtaty poshuku za: “Naghirnyj Karabakh”. Dzerkalo tyzhnja. https://zn.ua/ukr/search/ query=%D0%BD%D0%B0%D0%B3%D1%96%D1%80%D0%BD%20%D0%BA%D0%B0%D1 %80%D0%B0%D0%B1%D0%B0%D1%85?date_start=&date_end=&news=on&article=on&- photo_video=on&interview=on. (stanom na ljutyj-berezenj 2021).

Rezul’taty poiska po: “Nagornyj Karabah”. Hetq. (2021). Nagornyj Karabah. https://hetq.am/ ru (po sostojaniju na 4 maja 2021).

Rezul’taty poiska po: “Arcah”. Hetq. https://hetq.am/ru/article/125347 (po sostojaniju na 4 maja 2021).

Rezul’taty poiska po: “Bejrut”. (2000–2021). Trend. https://www.trend.az/search?query=%D 0%B1%D0%B5%D0%B9%D1%80%D1%83%D1%82 (po sostojaniju na dekabr’-fevral’ 2020– 2021).

Rezul’taty poiska po: “Dzhavahk”. Hetq. https://hetq.am/ru/article/125347 (po sostojaniju na 4 maja 2021).

Sargasjan, Meri i Agalarjan, Kristine. (2020). Uchastvovavshemu v arcahskoj vojne dobrovol’cu iz Dzhavahka ne razreshajut vernut’sja domoj: ego v#ezd v Gruziju zapreshhen. Hetq. https://hetq.am/ru/article/124944 (po sostojaniju na 3 dekabrja 2020).

Saruhanjan, Vage. (2021). Turecko-azerbajdzhanskij tandem ispol’zoval v Arcahe francuzskie tehnologii. Oficial’nyj Parizh izbegaet kommentariev. Hetq. https://hetq.am/ru/article/130372 (po sostojaniju na 4 maja 2021).

Skulenko, Mykhajlo. (2009). Media-ideologhija file:///C:/Users/User/Downloads/178036-%D0%A2%D0%B5%D0%BA%D1%81%D1%82%20%D1%81%D1%82%D0%B 0%D1%82%D1%82%D1%96-393565-1-10-20190913.pdf (stanom na 9 travnja 2021 r.).

Khaj zhyve Ukrayna! (2013). Hetq. https://hetq.am/ru/article/31157 (po sostojanyju na 4 dekabrja 2013).

Khmylevsjka, Viktorija. (2021). Virmenija podala skarghu do JeSPL proty Azerbajdzhanu. Dzerkalo tyzhnja. https://zn.ua/ukr/WORLD/virmenija-pozivajetsja-do-jespl-proti-azerbajdzhanu.html (stanom na 2 ljutogho 2021).

Chunikhina, Svitlana. (2020). Svoji chuzhi: naprjamy produkuvannja i psykhologhichna rolj “inshogho” v ukrajinsjkomu suspiljstvi. Ideologhija i polityka. 2(16): 304–319.

Downloads

Published

2022-10-12

How to Cite

Kosiuk, O. (2022). Propaganda and journalism (in the context on the Second Karabath War) . European Journal of Transformation Studies, 10(1), 78–96. Retrieved from https://czasopisma.bg.ug.edu.pl/index.php/journal-transformation/article/view/7324

Issue

Section

Artykuły