Academic Scientific JournalsIn-service teachers mentoring teacher trainees: (Not always) constructive dialogue
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.26881/bp.2023.1.06Keywords:
student teaching, student teacher, teacher trainee, supervisor, mentor, menteeAbstract
The paper concerns the topic of student teaching in the context of preservice teacher training. More specifically, the paper examines the nature of relationship between in-service teachers who undertake the role of practicum supervisor and student teachers, potential entrants into teaching. Relationships are a two-way interaction and the quality of dialogue depends on the engagement of both parties, which means that it is both supervisor (mentor) and teacher trainee (mentee) who are responsible for the development of this relationship. The aim of the present study was, however, to explore the role of mentor in directing the mentoring process, engaging student teachers in dialogue and developing a working relationship with them. The respondents were English philology students who had elected teacher training as part of their degree. The research instruments – questionnaire and interview – sought to gather data on various aspects of respondents’ student teaching: primarily, the relation with their mentors, but also more general issues, such as their contacts with the school headteacher and the atmosphere at school. The results of the study show that while some mentors provide high-quality supervision and develop a genuine connection with their mentees, for about one-fifth of respondents cooperation with their supervisor was difficult. What we see as one of the problems is that the function and role of practicum supervisor is not regulated in any formal way. Supervisors are not informed on what is expected from them and are not prepared or trained for this function. Whether teacher trainees conduct their student teaching in a supportive environment seems to solely depend on the mentor’s personality traits and good will.
Downloads
References
Beutel, Denise, Rebecca Spooner-Lane (2009). “Building mentoring capabilities in experienced teachers”. The International Journal of Learning 16: 351–360.
Bradbury, Leslie U., Thomas R. Jr. Koballa (2008). “Borders to cross: Identifying sources of tension in mentor-intern relationships”. Teaching and Teacher Education 24: 2132–2145.
Crandall, JoAnn (2001). “Keeping up to date as an ESL or EFL professional”. In: Marianne Celce-Murcia (ed.). Teaching English as a Second or Foreign Language. Boston: Heinle & Heinle, 535–552.
Crasborn, Frank, Paul Hennisson, Niels Brouwer, Fred Korthagen, Theo Bergen (2008). “Promoting versatility in mentor teachers’ use of supervisory skills”. Teaching and Teacher Education. 24: 499-514.
Evertson, Carolyn M., Margaret W. Smithey (2000). “Mentoring effects on protégés’ classroom practice: An experimental field study”. Journal of Educational Research 93: 294–304.
Farrell, Thomas S. (2008). “Here’s the book, go teach the class’ ELT practicum support”. RELC Journal 39: 226–241.
Feiman-Nemser, Sharon (2003). “What new teachers need to learn”. Educational Leadership 60: 25–29.
Hauge, Trond E. (2000). “Student teachers’ struggle in becoming professionals: Hopes and dilemmas in teacher education”. In: Christopher Day, Alicia Fernandez, Trond E. Hauge, Jorunn Møller (eds.). The Life and Work of Teachers. London: Falmer Press, 157–168.
Healy, Charles, Alice Weichert (1990). “Mentoring relations: a definition to advance research and practice”. Educational Research 19: 17–21.
Hobson, Andrew J. (2002). “Student teachers’ perceptions of schoolbased mentoring in initial teacher training (ITT)”. Mentoring and Tutoring 10: 5–20.
Hobson, Andrew J., Patricia Ashby, Angi Malderez, Peter D. Tomlinson (2009). “Mentoring beginning teachers: What we know and what we don’t”. Teaching and Teacher Education 25: 207–216.
Hudson, Peter (2013a). “Desirable attributes and practices for mentees: mentor teachers’ expectations”. European Journal of Educational Research 2: 107–119.
Hudson, Peter (2013b). “Developing and sustaining successful mentoring relationships”. Journal of Relationships Research 4: 1–10.
Hudson, Peter (2013c). “Mentoring as professional development: ‘Growth for both’ mentor and mentee”. Professional Development in Education 39: 771–783.
Lindgren, Ulla (2006). “Professional support to novice teachers by mentoring”. In: Mateja Brejc (ed.). 31st Annual ATEE Conference. Portorož, Slovenia: National School for Leadership in Education, 725–737.
Lopez-Real, Francis, Tammy Kwan (2005). “Mentors’ perceptions of their own professional development during mentoring”. Journal of Education for Teaching 31: 15–24.
Marable, Michele A., Sharon L. Raimondi (2007). “Teachers’ perceptions of what was most (and least) supportive during their first year of teaching”. Mentoring and Tutoring: Partnership in Learning 15: 25–37.
Mihułka, Krystyna (2016). “O wartości praktyk pedagogiczno-dydaktycznych w kształceniu językowym”. Języki Obce w Szkole 4: 53– 63.
Pitton, Debra Eckerman (2006). Mentoring Novice Teachers: Fostering a Dialogue Process. Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Press.
Rajuan, Maureen, Douwe Beijaard, Nico Verloop (2007). “The role of the cooperating teacher: Bridging the gap between the expectations of cooperating teachers and student teachers”. Mentoring & Tutoring: Partnership in Learning 15: 223–242.
Rippon, Janice H., Margaret Martin (2006). “What makes a good induction supporter?”. Teaching and Teacher Education 22: 84–99.
Roehrig, Alysia D., Catherine M. Bohn, Jeannine E. Turner, Michael Pressley (2008). “Mentoring beginning primary teachers for exemplary teaching practices”. Teaching and Teacher Education 24: 684– 702.
Smagorinsky, Peter, Leslie S. Cook, Cynthia Moore, Alecia Y. Jackson, Pamela G. Fry (2004). “Tensions in learning to teach: Accommodation and the development of a teacher identity”. Journal of Teacher Education 55: 8–24.
Smith, Kim, Margaret McLay (2007). “Curates’ eggs? Secondary trainee teachers’ experience of the Graduate Teacher Programme and the Postgraduate Certificate in Education”. Journal of Education for Teaching 33: 35–54.
Szymańska-Tworek, Aleksandra, Agnieszka Turzańska (2016). “45 minutes within the four walls of a classroom: Problems and concerns of student teachers during their practicum”. Studia Anglica Resoviensia 13: 99–108.
Szymańska-Tworek, Aleksandra (2022). “Mentoring as professional development for mentors”. Theory and Practice of Second Language Acquisition 8: 1–22.
Timoštšuk, Inge, Aino Ugaste (2010). “Student teachers’ professional identity”. Teaching and Teacher Education 26: 1563–1570.
Walkiewicz, Beata (2006). “Opiekun praktyk pedagogicznych w szkole”. Języki Obce w Szkole 3: 49–53.
Yuan, Eric R. (2016). “The dark side of mentoring on pre-service language teachers’ identity formation”. Teaching and Teacher Education 55: 188–197.
