The Manaki Brothers. The Chroniclers of the “Third” Europe

Autor

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.26881/pan.2023.30.01

Słowa kluczowe:

Manaki Brothers, Early Cinema, European Cinema, Documentary Film

Abstrakt

At the time of the birth of cinema at the turn of the 19th and 20th centuries, one more area was created on the cultural map of Europe, next to the West and the East. In the heart of this “third” Europe, under the rule of the Ottoman Empire, worked famous photographers of Wallachian origin, Janaki and Milton Manaki, their film work made them famous in the early 20th century as pioneers of “Balkan cinema”. Most of the films that have survived to this day were made in the Ottoman period. They are a testimony of everyday life as well as important events that influenced the course of the history of the region. The study of the life and work of the Manaki brothers seems to be dominated by the least important aspect, that is, the question of their origin and nationality. Their films are included in many national cinema discourses in the Balkans, from North Macedonia, through Greece, Romania, to Albania and Turkey. This article, representing a synthesis of brighter research, is, on the one hand, an attempt to organize (objective) knowledge about the lives and works of the Manaki brothers, and on the other hand, an in-depth introduction to their film work.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Bibliografia

“Slovenski narod”, 02.04.1904, http://www.dlib.si/stream/URN:NBN:SI:DOCO242T4KM/c6e3468b-4eea-431f-be48-31afef01e1d5/PDF, Accessed: 04.07.2023.

Bechev, D. (2009). Historical Dictionary of the Republic of Macedonia, Historical Dictionaries of Europe. No. 68. Lanham: Scarecrow Press.

Boué, A. (1840). La Turquie d’Europe. Paris: chez Bertrand.

Çeliktemel-Thomen, Ö. (2009). The Curtain of Dreams: Early Cinema in Istanbul 1896-1923. Budapest. https://www.etd.ceu.edu›celiktemel-thomen_ozde. Accessed: 20.07.2023.

Christodoulou, C. (1997). The Manakis Brothers: The Greek Pioneers of the Balkanic Cinema. Thessaloniki: Organization for the Cultural Capital of Europe.

Creţulescu, V. (2015). The Aromanian-Romanian National Movement (1859-1905): An Analytical Model, “Balcanica Posnaniensia” XXII/1 Ius Valachicum I. Poznań – Bucharest, pp. 99-119.

Dimovski – Colev G. (2007). Bitola and its Citizens Throughout the Centuries. In: L. Andonovska, N. Gorgievski, B. Nikolov, …(eds.). Значајни личности за Битола.

Distinguished people for Bitola, Bitola: NUUB “St. Clement Ohridski”, pp. 9-16. http:// nuub.hopto.org/greenstone3/sites/localsite/collect/col11/index/assoc/HASHfc68.dir/ ZnacajniLicnostiZaBitola.pdf, Accessed: 10.04.2023.

Evren, B. (2013). Balkanların ve Türk Sinemasının İlk Yönetmenlerinden Manaki Kardeşler. “Hayal Perdesi” 37, pp. 72-76. https://www.tsa.org.tr/tr/yazi/yazidetay/17/ balkanlarin-ve-turk-sinemasinin-ilk-yonetmenlerinden--manaki-kardesler. Accessed: 10.04.2023.

Kardjilov, P. (2012).“Cinematograms” of a Balkan Conflict: Charles Rider Noble in Bulgaria, 1903–1904. “Film History”, Vol. 24, No. 3, Behind the Camera, pp. 302-323.

Kosanović, D. (1985). Počeci kinematografije na tlu Jugoslavije 1896/1918. Beograd: Institut za film, Univerzitet umetnosti.

Kosanović, D. (2000). Leksikon pionira filma i filmskih stvaralaca na tlu jugoslovenskih zemalja: 1896–1945. Beograd: Institut za film.

Manaki, M. – Interview. Radio Skopje. 5 December 1963.

Minov, N. (2021). The Vlachs in Macedonia in the 19th and 20th Centuries. “Balcanica Posnaniensia” XXVIII/1 Ius Valachicum II, Poznań, pp. 211-223.

Peterlić, A. (ed.) (1990) Filmska enciklopedija, Zagreb: Jugoslavenski leksikografski zavod “Miroslav Krleža”. Photo album of Bulgarian rebels/militias and events from the socio-political life in Bitola in 1908 to 1910, https://www.strumski.com/books/Brakja_Manaki_Fotografii_Bitola. pdf, Accessed: 12.05.2023.

Şentürk, R. (2020), Türk Sinema Tarihi̇ Yaziminda Dönemselleştirme Sorunu1. (The Periodization Problem in Writing the Turkish Cinema History). “Intermedia International e-Journal”, December; 7(13), https://dergipark.org.tr/en/download/article-file/1172944. Accessed: 24.07.2023.

Stardelov, I. (2014). Balkanların Işık Ressamları Manaki Kardeşler. Translation Erol Mahmud. İstanbul: Cinematheque of Macedonia.

Stardelov, I. (1997). Preservation of Manaki Brothers Film Heritage. “Journal of Film Preservation”, Volume XXVI, N° 54, Apr./avr., pp. 27-30.

Stathatos, J. (2015) The Three-way Mirror: Photography as Record, Mirror and Model of Greek Identity. In: P. Carabott, Y Hamilakis, E Papargyriou (eds.) Camera Graeca: Photographs, Narratives, Materialities, New York: Ashgate.

Tutui, M. (1). Balkan Cinema Versus Cinema Of The Balkan Nations, Romanian Film Archive, http://aqshf.gov.al/uploads/2.___Manakia_Bros_Pioneers_of_Balkan_ Cinema_Claimed_by_Six_Nations.pdf. Accessed: 16.07.2023.

Tutui, M. (2017). The Visual Heritage of Manakia Bros. in the Balkan Countries, Istanbul. https://www.academia.edu/37115198/The_Visual_Heritage_of_Manakia_Bros_in_the_ Balkan_Countries_docx. Accessed: 20.07.2023.

Tutui, M. (2021). Four Early Contributions of Romanian Filmmakers to Modernity. “Art and Modernity” #1 (11). pp.159-162.

Xoxha, A. (1994). Art i shtate ne Shqiperi. Tirana: Albin. Έξαρχος, Γ.Σ. (1991). Αδελφοί Μανάκια: Πρωτοπόροι του κινηματογράφου στα Βαλκάνια και το “Βλαχικόν Ζήτημα”. Αθήνα: Γαβριηλίδης.

Χριστοδούλου, Χ. Κ. (1989), Τα Φωτογενή Βαλκάνια των Αδελφών Μανάκη. Θεσσαλονίκ: Παρατηρητησ. Илинденски сведоштва (2017). Tом 3. Државниот архив на Република Македонија. Скопје.https://www.strumski.com/books/manaki_ilindenski_svedostva.pdf. Accessed: 24.07.2023.

Османли, T. (1997). Книга на предубедувања и противречности. “Кинопис”. бр. 17 (9). pp. 21–30.

Старделов, И. (1997). Балканските “сликари на светлината” во темнината на историјата (кон монографијата “Творештвото на браќата Манаки”). “Кинопис”. бр. 17 (9).

Старделов, И. (2003a). Мајсторот Михајло Зега – животопис достоен за историја (за Михајло Зега, фотограф и соработник на браќата Манаки). „Кинопис” бр 3.

Старделов, Игор (2003b). Манаки. Скопје: Кинотека на Македонија. Фотоалбум с фотографии на български четници и събития от обществено-политическия живот в Битоля, Битоля 1908–1910. [In:] Държавна агенция “Архиви”. България. https://www.strumski.com/books/Brakja_Manaki_Fotografii_Bitola.pdf. 24.07.2023.

Цуцуи М. (1997). Нови факти во врските на браќата Манаки со Романија. “Кинопис”, бр. 17 (9). Кинотека на Македонија. Скопје. 1997, pp. 31–38.

Films About the Manaki Brothers

Camera number 300 (Kamera broj 300, 1958, dir. Branko Ranitović,).

The Life and Work of the Manakias Brothers (Η ζωή και το έργο τον αδελφών Μανάκια, 1988, dir. Nikos Antonakos) Manakia Brothers (Αδελφοί Μανάκια, 1988, dir. Costas Andritsos).

Odysseus’ Gaze (Το βλέμμα του Οδυσσέα, 1995, dir. Theo Angelopoulos).

The Manakia Brothers – Pioneers of the Balkans (Fratii Manakia – pionierii din Balcani, 1995, dir. Manuela Tanase).

The Manakia Brothers (Fratii Manakia, 2002, dir. Sabina Pop).

The Homers of the Balkan film – the Manakia Brothers (Homerët e filmit ballkanik – vëllezërit Manaqi, 2011, dir. Petrit Ruka).

Manaki Brothers. Diary of a long look back (Frații Manakia. Jurnalul unei lungi priviri înapoi, 2016, dir. Eliza Zdru).

A Story in Photographs (Манаки- Приказна во слики, 2017/18, dir. Robert Jankuloski).

The Manaki Brothers (Manaki Kardeşler, 2019, TRT 2). Turkus – The first filmmakers from the Balkans the Manaki Brothers (Turkuaz - Balkanların İlk Sinemacıları Manaki Kardeşler, 2020, TRT Avaz).

Opublikowane

2023-12-28

Jak cytować

Guštin, M. (2023). The Manaki Brothers. The Chroniclers of the “Third” Europe . Panoptikum, (30), 11–32. https://doi.org/10.26881/pan.2023.30.01