Engineering Structures and Their (non)Taxation by Slovak Real Property Tax (in the V4 Context)
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.26881/gsp.2024.1.06Keywords:
real property tax, object of taxation, tax on buildings, engineering structures, utility lines, local government financingAbstract
The paper deals with real property tax regulation, especially in the Slovak Republic, but also in the rest of the Visegrad group countries (Czech Republic, Poland, and Hungary) in the context of its position and role in funding local self-governments in all the countries studied, with a particular focus on engineering structures as a potential object of taxation, which is excluded from taxation in Slovakia. The authors focus primarily on the legislation of the Slovak Republic, and using the comparative method, they search for models of (non)inclusion of these objects into real property taxation among the V4 countries. They draw conclusions on the different approaches applied and suggest the most comprehensive system is in Poland. Based on a comparison of the real property tax revenues in the countries studied, these different approaches can be connected to the low real property tax revenues in the Slovak Republic (and also in the Czech Republic).
Downloads
References
Belkovicsová D., Daň z nehnuteľností ako významný zdroj financovania územnej samosprávy, “Acta aerarii publici” 2020, nr. 1.
Bencsik A., A helyi önkormányzatok (pénzügyi) autonómiájáról, “Pro Publico Bono – Magyar Közigazgatás” 2017, nr. 1, https://bit.ly/3Urxarm.
Bird R.M., Slack E., International Handbook of Land and Property Taxation, Northampton 2004. Bird R.M., Slack E., Land and Property Taxation: A Review, World Bank 2002.
Bordás P., A települési adó kivetésének korlátai a Kúria joggyakorlatának fényében, Kúria 2021, http://bit.ly/3VxyH0h.
Bordás P., A települési adó rendszertani és gyakorlati kérdései, “Pro Publico Bono – Magyar Közigazgatás” 2015, nr. 3, http://bit.ly/3APVRXF.
Borsa D., Hulkó G., Király P.B., Pardavi L., A települési adók szabályozási környezete, gyakorlata és kihívásai: Van-e jelentősége a települési adónak krízishelyzetekben vagy egyáltalán?, “KözigazgatásTudomány” 2022, nr. 2.
Červená K., Olexová C., Realita zdaňovania nehnuteľností na Slovensku (ekonomický pohľad) [in:] Stav a perspektívy verejných financií v EÚ = The condition of public finances in the EU and their future perspectives, Košice 2022.
Ercsey Zs., Bencsik A., A helyi önkormányzatok pénzügyi autonómiájának átalakulása, “Glossa Iuridica” 2020, nr. 1–2. European Commission, Taxes in Europe database, https://ec.europa.eu/taxation_customs/tedb/ index.html.
Explanatory Report on the Proposal of the Members of the National Council of the Slovak Republic Milan Vetrák, Petr Liba, Richard Nemec and Ján Szőllős for the Issuance of the Act on the Special Structure Tax and on Amendment of Certain Acts.
Hoffman I., Only a Theoretical Possibility of the Ad Valorem Property Tax System – the Regulation on Immovable Property Taxes in Hungary, “Analysis and Studies CASP” 2019, no. 2.
Hulkó G., A cseh, szlovák és lengyel helyi adók és illetékek szabályozási rendszerének elemzése, különös tekintettel a szabályozás gyakorlati problémáira [in:] A települési adók elmélete és gyakorlata különös tekintettel Győr-Moson-Sopron Megyére, ed. L. Pardavi, Győr 2022.
Hulkó G., A V4-országok helyi önkormányzati rendszerének összehasonlító elemzése [in:] A helyi önkormányzatok nemzetközi környezete, ed. E. Farkasné Gasparics, Budapest 2021.
Hulkó G., Fehér J., Hungary [in:] Real Property Taxes and Property Markets in CEE Countries and Central Asia, eds. M. Radvan, R. Franzsen, W.J. McCluskey, F. Plimmer, Maribor 2021.
Hulkó G., Pardavi L., Practical Experience and the Significance of the Settlement Tax in Hungary, “Annual Center Review” 2022, no. 14–15.
Liptáková K., Rigová Z., Financial creditworthiness of Slovak municipalities [in:] Interpolis ‘20, eds. D. Cevárová et al., Banská Bystrica 2020.
Miemiec W., Zawadzka P., Poland [in:] Real Property Taxes and Property Markets in CEE Countries and Central Asia, eds. M. Radvan, R. Franzsen, W.J. McCluskey, F. Plimmer, Maribor 2021.
Mrkývka P., Některé úvahy o materiálním základu veřejné správy, “Časopis pro právní vědu a praxi” 2003, nr. 2.
National Council of the Slovak Republic, Details of the bill: Act of 22 December 2022 on the tax on a special structure, amending certain acts, returned by the President of the Slovak Republic to the National Council of the Slovak Republic for reconsideration, https://www.nrsr.sk/web/Default. aspx?sid=zakony/zakon&MasterID=9041.
Papcunová V., Balážová E., Agh P., The Evaluation of the Relations Between the State Budget and the Local Self-Government Budgets (Case Study of the Slovak Republic) [in:] 22nd International Colloquium on Regional Sciences. Conference Proceedings, eds. V. Klímová, V. Žítek, Brno 2019.
Papcunová V., Országhová D., Hornyák Gregáňová R., Evaluation of Tax Incomes of Municipalities in Conditions of the Slovak and Czech Republics, “Acta Universitatis Bohemiae Meridionalis: scientific journal for economics, management and trade” 2018, no. 2.
Pardavi L., Az önkormányzati adók és a közteherviselés [in:] A települési adók elmélete és gyakorlata különös tekintettel Győr-Moson-Sopron Megyére, ed. idem, Győr 2022.
Poliak L., Finančná autonómia obcí – mikroekonomické východiská, “Societas et Iurisprudentia” 2016, nr. 1.
Radvan M., Correction Elements in Case of Czech Local Charges [in:] The Challenges of Local Government Financing in the Light of European Union Regional Policy, eds. P. Mrkývka et al., Brno 2018.
Radvan M., Major Problematic Issues in the Property Taxation in the Czech Republic, “Analysis and Studies CASP” 2019, no. 2.
Románová A., Adequacy of Current System of Property Taxation in the Slovak Republic [in:] Real Property Taxes and Property Markets in CEE Countries and Central Asia, eds. M. Radvan, R. Franzsen, W.J. McCluskey, F. Plimmer, Maribor 2021.
SITA, Eustream will not have to pay the pipe tax, MPs agree with President Čaputová’s comment, 17 February 2023, https://sita.sk/venergetike/eustream-nebude-musiet-platit-dan-z-ruryposlanci-sa-stotoznili-s-pripomienkou-prezidentky-caputovej/.
Vartašová A., Buildings & Structures as the Object of Real Property Taxes in the Countries of Visegrad Group [in:] Challenges of Contemporary Tax Law: Jubilee Book Dedicated to Professor Włodzimierz Nykiel on His 70th Anniversary, Łódź 2023 – in print.
Vartašová A., Komparácia systémov miestnych daní v krajinách Vyšehradskej štvorky [in:] Miestne dane v krajinách Vyšehradskej štvorky: zborník vedeckých prác, ed. K. Liptáková, Prague 2021.
Vartašová A., Červená K., Finančné hospodárenie mesta Košice v kontexte pandémie Covid-19 [in:] 4. Slovak-Czech days of tax law: Taxation of Virtual Currency and Digital Services, Košice 2021.
Vartašová A., Červená K., Real Property Tax in the Countries of Visegrad Group – Comparative View, “Studia Iuridica Lublinensia” 2022, no. 1.
Vybíhal V., Comparative study of the impact of local taxes and other revenues on the financial self- -suffiency of municipalities [in:] PUBLICY 2020 I. – 30 rokov verejnej správy, eds. P. Horváth, J. Machyniak, Trnava 2020.
ZMOS, Samosprávy: Zvýšenie daňového bonusu môže spôsobiť dvojitý postih, November 29, 2022, https://www.zmos.sk/samospravy--zvysenie-danoveho-bonusu-moze-sposobit-dvojitypostih-oznam/mid/405616/.html.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Gdańsk Legal Studies

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
Academic Scientific Journals
