In Search of Electronic Evidence – European Production Order and Other Instruments for International Obtaining of Data for Criminal Proceedings

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.26881/gsp.2024.2.03

Keywords:

electronic evidence, criminal proceedings, European cooperation in criminal matters, Internet service providers, principle of territoriality, European Investigation Order, principle of mutual recognition

Abstract

In July 2023, after more than five years of negotiations, the EU adopted the Regulation on European Production Orders and European Preservation Orders for electronic evidence. The regulation introduces a new paradigm for European cooperation in criminal matters, allowing authorities in one Member State to issue a direct binding order to a service provider in another Member State to produce data, in principle without the involvement of the latter’s authorities. This solution, not without controversy, responds to the increasingly pressing need for effective means of obtaining electronic data for criminal proceedings. The purpose of the article is to outline why the collection of electronic evidence poses several legal and practical problems, how they have been attempted to be dealt with and to analyse the new regulation and its key implications.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Clarke R.A., Morell M.J., Stone G.R., Sunstein C.R., Swire P., Liberty and Security in a Changing World. Report and Recommendations of the President’s Review Group on Intelligence and Communications Technologies, 12 December 2013, https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/sites/default/files/docs/2013-12-12_rg_final_report.pdf.

Corhay M., Private Life, Personal Data Protection and the Role of Service Providers: The EU e-Evidence Proposal, „European Papers” 2021, vol 6, no. 1.

Daskal J., A New UK-US Data Sharing Agreement: A Tremendous Opportunity, If Done Right, justsecurity.org, February 2016, https://www.justsecurity.org/29203/british-searches-america- -tremendous-opportunity/.

Daskal J., The Un-Territoriality of Data, „Yale Law Journal” 2015, vol. 125, no. 2.

Daskal J., Unpacking the CLOUD Act, „eucrim” 2018, issue 4.

Franssen V., The Belgian Internet Investigatory Powers Act – A Model to Pursue at European Level?, „European Data Protection Law Review” 2017, vol. 3, issue 4.

Franssen V., Tosza S., Cambridge Handbook of Digital Evidence in Criminal Matters, Cambridge 2023.

González Fuster G., Vázquez Maymir S., Cross-border Access to E-Evidence: Framing the Evidence, CEPS Papers series, Brussels 2020, https://www.ceps.eu/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/ LSE2020-02_Cross-border-Access-to-E-Evidence.pdf.

Kent G., The Mutual Legal Assistance Problem Explained, The Center for Internet and Society, 23 February 2015, http://cyberlaw.stanford.edu/blog/2015/02/mutual-legal-assistance-problem-explained.

Krishnamurthy V., Cloudy with a Conflict of Laws: How Cloud Computing Has Disrupted the Mutual Legal Assistance Treaty System and Why It Matters, Berkman Klein Center Research Publication No. 2016-3, https://ssrn.com/abstract=2733350.

Kusak M., Europejski nakaz dochodzeniowy – przełom w dziedzinie europejskiego ścigania karnego?, „Ruch Prawniczy, Ekonomiczny i Socjologiczny” 2012, t. 74, z. 4.

LaFave W.R., Search and Seizure: A Treatise on the Fourth Amendment, 5th ed., St. Paul (oct. 2017 update).

Ligeti K., Robinson G., Sword, Shield and Cloud: Toward a European System of Public-Private Orders for Electronic Evidence in Criminal Matters? [w:] Surveillance and Privacy in the Digital Age: European, Transatlantic and Global Perspectives, eds. V. Mitsilegas, N. Vavoula, Oxford–New York 2021.

Mitsilegas V., The Privatisation of Mutual Trust in Europe’s Area of Criminal Justice: The Case of E-evidence, „Maastricht Journal of European and Comparative Law” 2018, vol. 25, issue 3.

Rojszczak M., CLOUD act agreements from an EU perspective, „Computer Law & Security Review” 2020, vol. 3.

Sieber U., Neubert C.-W., Transnational Criminal Investigations in Cyberspace: Challenges to National Sovereignty [w:] Max Planck Yearbook of United Nations Law, vol. 20 (2016), eds. F. Lachenmann, T.J. Röder, R. Wolfrum, Leiden 2017.

Tosza S., All evidence is equal, but electronic evidence is more equal than any other: The relationship between the European Investigation Order and the European Production Order, „New Journal of European Criminal Law” 2020, vol. 11, issue 2.

Tosza S., Cross-Border Gathering of Electronic Evidence: Mutual Legal Assistance, Its Shortcomings and Remedies [w:] Société numérique et droit pénal: Belgique, France, Europe, sous la direction de V. Franssen, D. Flore, Bruxelles 2019.

Tosza S., Internet service providers as law enforcers and adjudicators. A public role of private actors, „Computer Law & Security Review” 2021, vol. 43.

Tosza S., Mutual Recognition by Private Actors in Criminal Justice? E-Evidence Regulation and Service Providers as the New Guardians of Fundamental Rights, „Common Market Law Review” 2023, vol. 61.

Tosza S., Mutual Recognition by Private Actors in Criminal Justice? Service Providers as Gatekeepers of Data and Human Rights Obligations, September 19, 2019, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/ papers.cfm?abstract_id=3517878.

Tosza S., The E-Evidence Package is Adopted: End of a Saga or Beginning of a New One?, „European Data Protection Law Review” 2023, no. 2.

Published

2024-06-15

How to Cite

Tosza, S. (2024). In Search of Electronic Evidence – European Production Order and Other Instruments for International Obtaining of Data for Criminal Proceedings. Gdańsk Legal Studies, (2(63)/2024), 37–55. https://doi.org/10.26881/gsp.2024.2.03