Further Discussion Relating to the Concept of Margin of Appreciation in the Context of Protocol No. 15 to the ECHR
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.26881/gsp.2025.1.12Keywords:
margin of appreciation, human rights, Convention on Human Rights, universality, subsidiarity, proportionalityAbstract
One of the most important and yet much-debated institutions in the Council of Europe system is the concept of margin of appreciation. The expansion process of the Council of Europe has increased the cultural and legal heterogeneity of the Council of Europe. The European system of protection is subsidiary to states’ protection systems, which are rooted in different cultural and legal traditions. At the same time, accession to the European Convention on Human Rights entails the search for a uniform common standard of human rights protection. The fundamental and constantly recurring question, therefore, was whether, within the framework of the system of creating European standards and a unified system of protection, there is room for differentiation, and if so, in what areas. The answer to these questions was the concept of margin of appreciation, developed since the 1970s in the jurisprudence of the Council of Europe. In 2012, it was introduced by Protocol 15 of the Council of Europe into the preamble of the Convention. It went from being a jurisprudential institution to one that is rooted in the text of the Convention itself. This underscores the importance attributed to the concept of margin of appreciation in the relationship between the European Court and States, while also seeking to strengthen the principle of subsidiarity. The question that arises in this context is whether the changes introduced by Protocol 15 will have a significant impact on the functioning of the Court and will lead to a change in jurisprudence. Only time will tell. Much depends on how the Court will apply the newly added principles and whether it will give them more weight now that they have been incorporated into the preamble of the Convention.
Downloads
References
Garlicki L., Wartości lokalne a orzecznictwo ponadnarodowe – „kulturowy margines oceny” w orzecznictwie strasburskim?, „Europejski Przegląd Sądowy” 2008, nr 4.
Greer S., The interpretation of the European Convention on Human Rights: Universal Principle of margin of appreciation, „UCL Human Rights Review” 2010, vol. 3.
Greer S., The Margin of Appreciation: Interpretation and Discretion Under the European Convention on Human Rights, Human Rights Files No. 17, Strasbourg 2000.
Jóźwicki W., Ograniczenia w korzystaniu z praw zagwarantowanych w Międzynarodowym Pakcie Praw Gospodarczych, Społecznych i Kulturalnych a koncepcja marginesu swobody oceny [w:] Między prawem a polityką. Księga jubileuszowa dedykowana profesor Hannie Suchockiej, red. B. Kaniewska, T. Walas, K. Urbaniak, Poznań 2023.
Jóźwicki W., Ultra vires and constitutional identity control – apples and oranges or two drops of water? Some remarks on the possible role of the New Mixed Chamber of the Court of Justice in the context of the „sequential” model of adjudication on art. 4(2) TEU, Verfassungsblog, 15 June 2020, https://verfassungsblog.de/ultra-vires-and-constitutional-identity-control-applesand-oranges-or-two-drops-of-water/.
Kędzia Z., An East-European Perspective on an All-European System of Human Rights Protection [w:] Perspectives of an all-European System of Human Rights Protection: The Role of the Council of Europe, the CSCE, and the European Communities: Proceedings and Recommendations of an International Conference, Poznań, Poland, 8–11 October 1990.
Kowalski M., Powrót czarnoksiężnika – uwagi na tle wyroku Wielkiej Izby ETPCz z 18.03.2011 r. w sprawie Lautsi przeciwko Włochom, „Forum Prawnicze” 2011, nr 4–5(6–7).
Lester A., Universality vs. Subsidiarity: A reply, „European Human Rights Law Review” 1998, no. 1.
Łukaszczuk A., Ograniczanie wolności wypowiedzi i wyrażania opinii w wybranych orzeczeniach Europejskiego Trybunału Praw Człowieka, „Przegląd Prawa i Administracji” 2021, nr 126, seria: Acta Universitatis Wratislaviensis, nr 4056.
Macdonald R.St.J., The margin of appreciation in the jurisprudence of the ECHR [w:] International Law at the time of its codification. Essays in honour of Roberto Ago, Milan 1987.
Osiatyński W., Rights in New Constitutions of East Central Europe, „Columbia Human Rights Law Review” 1994, vol. 26.
de la Rasilla del Moral I., The Increasingly Marginal Appreciation of the Margin-of-Appreciation Doctrine, „German Law Journal” 2006, vol. 7, no. 6.
Spielmann D., Allowing the Right Margin the European Court of Human Rights and the National Margin of Appreciation Doctrine: Waiver or Subsidiarity of European Review?, CELS Working Paper Series, February 2012.
Stanculescu D., Subsidiarity and the margin of appreciation in Protocol 15 of the ECHR: Substantial or symbolic change?, 5 July 2021, https://www.publicinternationallawandpolicygroup.org/ lawyering-justice-blog/2021/7/5/subsidiarity-and-the-margin-of-appreciation-in-protocol15-of-the-echr-substantial-or-symbolic-change.
Suchocka H., Europejska Konwencja Praw Człowieka a prawo wewnętrzne państw-członków Rady Europy – wzajemne zależności [w:] Konstytucja i gwarancje jej przestrzegania. Księga pamiątkowa ku czci prof. Janiny Zakrzewskiej, kom. red. J. Trzciński, A. Jankiewicz, Warszawa 1996.
Suchocka H., Zmieniająca się funkcja idei tożsamości konstytucyjnej [w:] Rządy prawa jako wartość uniwersalna. Księga jubileuszowa Profesora Krzysztofa Wójtowicza, red. A. Kozłowski, Wrocław 2022.
The Doctrine of the Margin of Appreciation under the European Convention on Human Rights: Its Legitimacy in Theory and Application in Practice, „Human Rights Law Journal” 1998, vol. 19, no. 1.
Wieruszewski R., Human Rights and current Constitutional Debates in Central and Eastern European Countries [w:] The Strength of Diversity: Human Rights and Pluralist Democracy, eds. A. Rosas, J. Helgesen, Dordrecht–Boston–London 1992.
Wiśniewski A., Koncepcja marginesu oceny w orzecznictwie Europejskiego Trybunału Praw Człowieka, Gdańsk 2008.
Zubik M., Prawo konstytucyjne współczesnej Polski, wyd. 4, Warszawa 2023.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Gdańsk Legal Studies

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
Academic Scientific Journals
