Can Judicial Jurisprudence Contribute to the Constitutional Right to Housing?
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.26881/gsp.2025.1.19Keywords:
right to housing and the Constitution, credits in Swiss francs, CJEU case law, invalidity of credit agreements in Swiss francs, abusive clauses, consumer protectionAbstract
This gloss on the rulings of the CJEU in cases involving so-called “Swiss franc loans” arises against the backdrop of the recent discussion of the right to housing. It is asserted that housing cannot be a commodity, which it is, of course, as a consequence of the high price of housing in relation to wages. Although Article 75 of the Constitution stipulates that public authorities should pursue a policy conducive to meeting the housing needs of citizens, this right is treated as a secondary right. A serious threat to citizens turned out to be taking out loans in Swiss francs, largely for the purchase of housing, because of the freeing of the rate of exchange for the Swiss franc. In this case, the saviour of borrowers turned out to be the CJEU, which issued several rulings in favour of consumers. In the gloss, I comment on two rulings, from 3 October 2022 that a contract can be invalidated in the event of the existence of an abusive clause, and from 15 June 2023, that remuneration for the use of a bank’s capital is contrary to EU law. So we have a situation in which the CJEU was on the consumer’s side from the very beginning. Polish courts under the influence of the CJEU began to rule similarly. Hence the conclusion follows that it was judicial power that created housing policy in this segment of the housing market.
Downloads
References
Banasiński C., UOKiK: Każdy sam powinien decydować o wyborze kredytu, money.pl, 4.07.2006, https://www.money.pl/banki/wiadomosci/artykul/uokik;kazdy;sam;powinnien;decydowac; o;wyborze;kredytu,127,0,169343.html.
Bernaczyk M., Konstytucyjne obowiązki państwa do podejmowania działań w zakresie zaspokajania potrzeb mieszkaniowych jednostki [w:] Realizacja i ochrona konstytucyjnych wolności i praw jednostki w polskim porządku prawnym, red. M. Jabłoński, Wrocław 2014.
Bodnar A., Mieszkanie prawem, a nie towarem, https://adambodnar.pl/mieszkanie-prawema-nie-towarem/.
Komentarz do wyroku TSUE z dnia 15 czerwca 2023 r., C-520/21. Kontekst sprawy – pytanie prejudycjalne Sądu Rejonowego dla Warszawy-Śródmieścia, https://www.kochanski.pl/komentarz- -do-wyroku-tsue-c-520-21-z-15-czerwca-2023-roku/.
Popiołek A., Bank dostanie waloryzację kapitału za kredyty we frankach? Gdański sąd po stronie banków, nie frankowiczów, „Gazeta Wyborcza”, 13.07.2023, https://wyborcza.biz/biznes/ 7,147582,29966985,bank-dostanie-waloryzacje-kapitalu-za-kredyty-we-frankach-gdanski. html#S.embed.
Sudak I., Banki, KNF i NBP frankowiczom nie przepuszczą. Mają oddać tyle, ile realnie pożyczyli, „Gazeta Wyborcza”, 23.01.2024, https://wyborcza.biz/biznes/7,147582,30621340,banki-knfi-nbp-frankowiczowi-nie-przepuszcza-ma-oddac-tyle.html.
Szymański D., Siedem lat temu wybuchła frankowa bomba. Dzisiaj pisze się jej kolejny rozdział, money.pl, 15.01.2022, https://www.money.pl/gospodarka/siedem-lat-temu-wybuchlafrankowa-bomba-dzisiaj-pisze-sie-jej-kolejny-rozdzial-6726651025886048a.html.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Gdańsk Legal Studies

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
Academic Scientific Journals
