Withdrawal of an A1 Certificate on the Initiative of the Issuing Institution

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.26881/gsp.2025.2.15

Keywords:

Portable Document A1, PD A1, withdrawal of a PD A1, binding effect of a PD A1, A1 Certificate, posting of workers, social security, Court of Justice of the European Union, CJEU

Abstract

The CJEU ruling in case C-422/22 confirms the importance of dialogue and conciliation in cases concerning the determination of social security legislation applicable in cross-border situations. A portable document certifying the applicable legislation of one Member State (a PD A1) is a declaratory decision. It remains in force until the competent institution that issued it withdraws it or invalidates it. This principle increases legal certainty and guarantees to the insured person the enforcement of the most important benefits of social security coordination, namely: avoidance of double contributions and double social security benefits, protection of acquired rights and rights in course of acquisition, and, above all, protection against the loss of social security upon crossing the EU internal borders. The preliminary question of the Supreme Court (Poland) to CJEU referred to the need for the Polish Social Insurance Institution (ZUS) to enter into a dialogue procedure with the competent French institution (Urssaf) before withdrawing the PD A1 in a situation where it was established ex post that there were no grounds for its issuance under Article 13 of Regulation 883/2004/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council on the coordination of social security systems. The Court confirmed that that procedure is intended to resolve discrepancies in the assessment of which legislation is applicable between two or more competent institutions. However, it is not required as a prerequisite for withdrawing the A1 certificate on its own initiative by the issuing institution.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Barnard C., The Substantive Law of the EU. The Four Freedoms, Oxford 2015.

Benio M., Nowelizacja zasad delegowania pracowników, “Europejski Przegląd Sądowy” 2018, no. 6.

Bermejo D.C., Millán J.M., The binding nature of posting PDA1 issued under EU social security Coordination Regulations and the possible role of national courts, “ERA Forum” 2023, vol. 24.

De Lucia L., From Mutual Recognition to EU Authorization: A Decline of Transnational Administrative Acts?, “Italian Journal of Public Law” 2016, vol. 8, no. 1.

De Wispelaere F., De Smedt L., Pacolet J., Posting of workers. Report on A1 Portable Documents issued in 2023, Luxembourg 2025.

Dzienisiuk D., Ubezpieczenia społeczne, koordynacja systemów zabezpieczenia społecznego, zaświadczenie A1. Glosa do wyroku SN z dnia 18 stycznia 2017, III UK 42/16, “Orzecznictwo Sądów Polskich” 2018, no. 2.

Eliantonio M., Information Exchange in European Administrative Law: A Threat to Effective Judicial Protection?, “Maastricht Journal of European and Comparative Law” 2016, vol. 23, no. 3.

Grygutis J., Status prawny pracownika delegowanego na rynku wewnętrznym Unii Europejskiej, Warszawa 2023.

Holubec V., Binding effect of the A1 Certificate in the case-law of the Court of Justice of the European Union [in:] Liber Amicorum Bernhard Spiegel, Brussels 2024.

Jorens Y., Cross-border EU Employment and its Enforcement. An Analysis of the Labour and Social Security Law Aspects and a Quest for Solutions, Cham 2022.

Kiełbasa M., “Nowy wspaniały świat (delegowania pracowników)?”, czyli o zasadności (niektórych) zmian w delegowaniu pracowników w Unii Europejskiej słów kilka [in:] Verba volant, scripta manent: księga jubileuszowa dedykowana profesor Bogusławie Gneli, eds. A. Kaźmierczyk, K. Michałowska, M. Szaraniec, Warszawa 2023.

Kiełbasa M., Prawa socjalne w Unii Europejskiej a granice swobód rynku wewnętrznego, Warszawa 2017.

Kiełbasa M., Szaraniec M., Mędrala M., Benio M., Posting of workers from and to Poland. Facts and figures, 2022, Leuven: POSTING.STAT project VS/2020/0499.

Lach D.E., Procedura wycofania zaświadczenia A1 a wsteczne włączenie delegowanego pracownika do systemu zabezpieczenia społecznego państwa wykonywania pracy, „Praca i Zabezpieczenie Społeczne” 2022, no. 8.

Langlois N., A1 certificate withdrawal upon initiative of the issuing institution: What procedure applies? (Case C-422/22, Zakład Ubezpieczeń Społecznych Oddział w Toruniu), https://eulawlive.com/analysis-a1-certificate-withdrawal-upon-initiative-of-the-issuing-institution-whatprocedure-applies-case-c-422-22-zaklad-ubezpieczen-spolecznych-oddzial-w-toruniu-bynicolas-l/#.

Tomaszewska M., Rozdział 9. Delegowanie pracowników a migracja pracowników w ramach świadczenia usług [in:] System prawa pracy, t. 10: Międzynarodowe publiczne prawo pracy. Standardy europejskie, ed. K.W. Baran, Warszawa 2020.

Rennuy N., Posting of workers: Enforcement, compliance and reform, “European Journal of Social Security” 2020, vol. 22, no. 1.

Szybkie A., Weryfikacja ustawodawstwa właściwego a ochrona pracownika migrującego na gruncie prawa Unii Europejskiej o koordynacji systemów zabezpieczenia społecznego, „Przegląd Prawa i Administracji” 2022, vol. 130.

Szypniewski M., Ufać, ale kontrolować? Zasada lojalnej współpracy państw członkowskich Unii Europejskiej a zaświadczenie A1, “Praca i Zabezpieczenie Społeczne” 2022, no. 2.

Downloads

Published

2025-06-16

How to Cite

Kiełbasa, M., & Benio, M. (2025). Withdrawal of an A1 Certificate on the Initiative of the Issuing Institution. Gdańsk Legal Studies, (2(67)/2025), 220–230. https://doi.org/10.26881/gsp.2025.2.15