International Data Transfers post Schrems – Moving Towards Solutions
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.26881/gsp.2021.4.02Keywords:
transfer of data to third country; adequacy; standard contractual clauses; GDPRAbstract
International data transfers are both essential for the modern world and a major source of risks to the protection of personal data. In this, we can speak of a clash between an important multifaceted objective and the protection of a complex fundamental human right with implications going far beyond that right itself.
The goal must be to facilitate data privacy respecting international data transfers. However, agreement on this goal – even if widespread – does not necessarily signal agreement on how we reach that goal. To make progress, we must proceed with caution and yet avoid getting bogged down in the unavoidable challenges, such as definitional challenges, we will face.
This article canvasses a selection of key considerations that ought to be kept in mind when we discuss approaches to international data transfers. However, to prepare ground for that discussion, it first sets the scene by examining the so-called Schrems II decision, its larger context and background, as well as some of the reactions we have seen to that decision.
Downloads
References
Bentzen H., Svantesson D., Jurisdictional Challenges Related to DNA Data Processing in Transnational Clouds [in:] Trans-Atlantic Data Privacy Relations as a Challenge for Democracy, eds D. Svantesson, D. Kloza, Cambridge–Antwerpia–Portland 2017.
Bygrave L., International agreements to protect personal data [in:] Global Privacy Protection: The First Generation, eds J. Rule, G. Greenleaf, Cheltenham 2008, revised in 2017, available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3072270 [accessed 2021.09.09].
Chander A., Is Data Localization a Solution for Schrems II?, “Georgetown Law Faculty Publications and Other Works” 2020, 2300, https://scholarship.law.georgetown.edu/facpub/2300 [accessed: 2021.09.09].
Chander A., Le U., “Data Nationalism”, Emory Law Journal 2015, vol. 64/3.
Korff D., “Korff on Kuner: Schrems II Re-Examined,” 3 September 2020, https://www.ianbrown. tech/2020/09/03/korff-on-kuner-schrems-ii-re-examined/ [accessed: 2021.09.09].
Kuner Ch., “Schrems II Re-Examined”, Verfassungsblog.de 25 August 2020, https://verfassungsblog.de/schrems-ii-re-examined/ [accessed: 2021.09.09].
Kuner Ch., “International Agreements, Data Protection, and EU Fundamental Rights on the International State: Opinion 1/15, EU-Canada PNR”, Common Market Law Review 2018, no. 55.
Mascalzoni D., Bentzen H. et al., “Are Requirements to Deposit Data in Research Repositories Compatible With the European Union’s General Data Protection Regulation?”, Annals of Internal Medicine 2019, no. 170(5).
Palfrey J., Gasser U., Interop: The Promise and Perils of Highly Interconnected Systems, New York 2012.
Polčák R., Svantesson D., Information Sovereignty – Data Privacy, Sovereign Powers and the Rule of Law, Cheltenham 2017.
Svantesson D., “A ‘layered approach’ to the extraterritoriality of data privacy laws,” International Data Privacy Law 2013, no. 3(4).
Svantesson D., “A legal method for solving issues of Internet regulation; applied to the regulation of cross-border privacy issues,” European University Institute Working Paper LAW 2010, no. 18.
Svantesson D., “Cross-border data transfers after the CJEU’s Safe Harbour Decision – A tale of Gordian Knots,” Alternative Law Journal 2016, no. 41(1).
Svantesson D., “Data localisation trends and challenges: Considerations for the review of the Privacy Guidelines,” OECD Digital Economy Papers 2020, no. 301, Paris, http://dx.doi. org/10.1787/7fbaed62-en [accessed: 2021.09.09].
Svantesson D., “The holy trinity of legal fictions undermining the application of law to the global Internet,” International Journal of Law and Information Technology 2015, vol. 23, no. 3.
Svantesson D., “What is ‘Law’, if ‘the Law’ is Not Something That ‘Is’? A Modest Contribution to a Major Question”, Ratio Juris 2013, no. 26(3), p. 456.
Svantesson D., Solving the Internet Jurisdiction Puzzle, Oxford 2017.
The EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR): A Commentary, eds Ch. Kuner et al., Oxford 2020.
Trans-Atlantic Data Privacy Relations as a Challenge for Democracy, eds D. Svantesson, D. Kloza, Cambridge–Antwerpia–Portland 2017.
Weber R.H., “Legal Interoperability as a Tool for Combating Fragmentation,” Global Commission on Internet Governance Paper Series Centre for International Governance Innovation 2014, no 4.
Academic Scientific Journals
