Refugees in Private International Law
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.26881/gsp.2022.1.01Keywords:
refugees; 1951 Geneva Convention; personal status of a refugee; private international law; personal connecting factors; nationality; domicile; habitual residence; simple residence; protection; asylum; recognition of marriages; parental care; guardianship; legal capacity.Abstract
The article deals with the issue of the legal status of refugees in the provisions of private international
law in force in Poland. The main problem in this context is the ambiguity of the concept
of “refugee”, which in a broader sense includes not only the addressees of the provisions of the
Geneva Convention of 28 July 1951 relating to the status of refugees (the so-called “Refugee
Convention”) but also other forced migrants who take advantage of protection on a different
legal basis – primarily asylum. Article 12 (1) of the Geneva Convention provides that the ‘personal
status’ of each refugee shall be governed by the law of the state of his/her domicile or, in
the absence of domicile, by the law of the state of his/her residence. The subject of scientific and
judicial debate is both the interpretation of this provision and its relationship with national law
such as Article 3 of the Polish Act of 4 February 2011, Private International Law. Within the scope
of its regulation, the Geneva Convention takes precedence over all national provisions pursuant
to Article 91 (2) and Article 241 of the Polish Constitution. As a result, in refugee “personal
status” cases, it becomes necessary to replace the connecting factor of nationality with another:
habitual residence or, alternatively, simple residence, as soon as it is established that the person
concerned is a refugee under the Geneva Convention. For other protected migrants, quite similar
legal effects will arise from the application of Article 3 (2) of the Polish Private International
Law of 2011. The aim of the contribution is to interpret the latter provision in a way that gives
due meaning to some unclear wording used by the legislator (e.g. “violation of fundamental
human rights”). It was emphasized that the court dealing with private law cases should characterize
a foreigner as a “refugee” autonomously, i.e. without the need to consult Polish or foreign
authorities competent in matters of migration and granting protection. At the same time,
moderation and caution are advisable, due to the fact that the connecting factor of nationality
continues to occupy a central place in the national legal provisions determining the law applicable
to various private-law relationships. Moreover, it is obvious that not every migrant can and
should be called a “refugee”, even in the broadest sense of the word.
Academic Scientific Journals
