Concept of the “Place Where the Damage Occurred” in the Event of Infringement of the Personal Rights of a Legal Person by the Publication on the Internet of Allegedly False Information Relating to the Legal Person

Authors

  • Joanna Szczęch Kancelaria prawna Cofila Asesores w okręgu Santa Cruz de Tenerife

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.26881/gsp.2022.1.09

Keywords:

personal rights, cross-border jurisdiction, internet, mosaic principle, centre of interest of a legal person, internet torts

Abstract

The commentary intends to determine the meaning of the “place where the damage occurred” in cases of online infringement of personal rights of legal persons. The analysis is based on the judgment of 17 October 2017, C-194/16, Bolagsupplysningen OÜ and Ingrid Ilsjan v Svensk Handel AB. The issues raised have been examined with the help of the most important judgments of the Court of Justice in recent years. First, an issue such as the plurality of personal rights in the Internet space has been analysed. Moreover, considerations were focused on the protection of personal rights of legal persons and analogies in the application of this protection, both to legal and natural persons. The considerations were based on previous judgments of the Court, different from the judgment in question. This was followed by a critical consideration of the application of the Mosaic Rule in online personal infringement cases, which continues to pose many problems in cross-border cases relating to the determination of jurisdiction. However, the bulk of the analysis was carried out by examining the connecting factor of the centre of interests of the allegedly injured person in order to define the concept of the place where the damage occurred. The issue at stake has been analysed in terms of its superiority over other connecting factors. It should be noted that the judgment on which this commentary is based is a novelty in the analysed matter, thus constituting a breakthrough in the jurisprudence of the Court of Justice. However, according to the conclusion of this paper, the commented ruling of the Court has not dispelled all doubts related to the raised issue.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Bizer A., International jurisdiction for violations of personality rights on the internet, „Common Market Law Review” 2018, vol. 6.

Elgar E., Conflict of Laws and the Internet, Pedro de Miguel Asensio, Cheltenham 2020.

Greenberg B.A., Rething Technology Neutrality, „Minnesota Law Review” 2016, vol. 4.

Hartley T., International Commercial Litigation: Text, Cases and Materials on Private International Law, Camabridge University Press 2020.

Magnus U., Mankowski P., Brussels I bis Regulation, Munich 2016.

Pontier J.A., Burg E., EU Principles on Jurisdiction and Recognition and Enforcement of Judgments in Civil and Commercial Matters according to the Case Law of the European Court of Justice, Haga 2004.

Rowley W., How to Stay Anonymous on the Internet, Disappearing from the Web (Internet Security, Darknet), Createspace Independent Publishing Platform, United States 2017.

Symeonides S.C., Cross-Border Infringement of Personality Rights via Internet, Holandia 2021.

Svantesson D.J.B., Private International Law and the Internet, Alphen aan den Rijn 2012.

Van Calster G., European Private International Law: Commercial Litigation in the EU, Leuven 2021.

Published

2022-03-15

How to Cite

Szczęch, J. (2022). Concept of the “Place Where the Damage Occurred” in the Event of Infringement of the Personal Rights of a Legal Person by the Publication on the Internet of Allegedly False Information Relating to the Legal Person. Gdańsk Legal Studies, (1(53)/2022), 139–154. https://doi.org/10.26881/gsp.2022.1.09

Issue

Section

Glosy i przegląd orzecznictwa