Changing the Club Affiliation (Transfer) of a Minor Player in the Light of the FIFA Regulations on the Status and Transfer of Players on the Example of FC Barcelona
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.26881/gsp.2022.1.10Keywords:
CAS, FC Barcelona, FC Barcelona transfer ban, transfer ban, 2014/A/3793, Regulations on the Status and Transfer of Players art. 19, art. 19 bis, transfer of minors, minor football player, sports law, RFEF, FIFAAbstract
The commentary provides a critical assessment of the judgment of the Court of Arbitration for Sport in Lausanne of 24 April 2015 in the case No 2014 / A / 3793. This proceeding was initiated by FC Barcelona’s appeal against the decision of the FIFA Appeal Committee. In this decision, the FIFA disciplinary authorities imposed a penalty on FC Barcelona for violating the provisions of the FIFA Regulations on the Status and Transfer of Players in the case of transfers of underage players from outside the territory of the European Union and the registration of players trained in La Masia to play in the colours of FC Barcelona. The commentary analyses the CAS judgment in the context of FIFA regulations and the norms of Spanish law in force at the time of its issuance. The Author used a comparative method in order to compare the compliance of national law with federal standards, and the judgment was analysed along with sanctions imposed by the Arbitration Tribunal for Sport in Lausanne, applying a purposeful interpretation of the provisions of FIFA Regulations on the Status and Transfer of Players. The paper also highlights the importance of arbitration as a method of resolving sports disputes and the importance of the so-called “sports law” as an emerging field of law that is also subject to scientific research. Due to the precedent nature of the judgment of the Court of Arbitration for Sport in Lausanne in the case No 2014/A/3793, the critical commentary to this judgment may be a starting point for a discussion on the appropriate interpretation of the provisions of the FIFA Regulations on the Status and Transfer of Players and the application of sanctions in the event of possible future violations of its provisions by other football clubs.
Downloads
References
Ashton N., Barca get transfer ban for 15 months, „Daily Mail” 3 April 2014.
Barcelona transfer ban: La Liga giants cannot sign players until 2016 after CAS reject appeal, The ban related to the ‘international transfer of minors’, „The Independent” 30 December 2014.
Cazacu G., The international legal norms regarding children football transfers, „Fiat Iustitia” 2017, no. 1.
Crefton A., Blues fury after FIFA refuses to delay ban, „Daily Mail” 9 March 2019.
Favre-Bulle X., Durante D., CAS arbitration proceedings: Is sports arbitration so different?, „Journal of International Trade and Arbitration Law” 2015, vol. 4, issue 2.
FIFA, Commentary on the Regulations on the Status and Transfer of Players, wersja z 2004 r., s. 59, https://www.thefa.com › december-2015-updates [dostęp: 16.01.2022].
Gardiner S., Welch R., Nationality and protectionism in football: why are FIFA’s “6+5 rule” and UEFA’s “home grown player rule” on the agenda, „Soccer & Sciety” 2011 vol. 12, no. 6.
Gilson E.T., Exploring the Court of Arbitration for Sport [w:] „Law Library Journal” 2006, vol. 98.
Głuszniewski M., Sąd ostateczny nad Barceloną. Zakaz transferów przez dwa najbliższe okna! Trybunał Arbitrażowy ds. Sportu podtrzymał swoją decyzję. Duma Katalonii nie może przeprowadzać transferów, „Przegląd Sportowy” z 30 grudnia 2014 r.
Lambo C., FIFA transfer regulations and UEFA player eligibility rules: major changes in European football and the negative effect on minors, „Emory International Law Review” 2011, vol. 25.
Lawton M., Gaughan J., City face shock transfer ban for two windows, „Daily Mail” 17 April 2018.
Lawton M., Transfer ban puts Chelsea in chaos, „Daily Mail” 23 February 2019.
Mahoney D., Doping appeals at the Court of Arbitration for Sport: Lessons from Essendon, „Boston College Law Review”, vol. 59: 1807.
Morcotti G., Barcelona suffer for not rotating their strike stars, „The Times” 18 April 2016.
Oliey J., Wenger: FIFA right to hit Barca with transfer ban, „Evening Standard” 4 April .
Shabalina E.A., The use of mediation procedure in dispute resolution processes of the UEFA Financial Control Body and the Court of Arbitration for Sport, „Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University Law”, s. 73, https://doi.org/10.21638/11701/spbu14.2018.105) [dostęp: 16.01.2022].
Smith R., Barcelona will fight transfer ban, „The Times” 3 April 2014.
Academic Scientific Journals
