Diffuse Constitutional Review in the Light of Poland’s Constitutional Court Crisis

Authors

  • Piotr Radziewicz Warsaw University of Technology

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.26881/gsp.2022.4.07

Keywords:

constitution, Constitutional Court, diffuse review, constitutional crisis, constitutional law

Abstract

This gloss comments on the judgment of a common court disapplying a duly enacted statute as incompatible with the Constitution. The court also decided to disapply the Constitutional Court’s judgment on the same subject because of the participation of a person elected to an already occupied seat. The District Court’s intention was to substitute itself for a Constitutional Court stripped of independence and impartiality. The intention was to protect the supremacy of the Constitution, human rights, and the rule of law. The purpose of this gloss is to examine more closely this new practice from the courts and the circumstances surrounding it. The actions taken by the courts lead to the propagation of the diffuse constitutional review of ordinary statutes as a sort of protective mechanism within a constitutional democracy.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Brewer-Carías A.R., Judicial Review in Comparative Law, Cambridge 1989.

de Morais C.B., Justica Constitutional II, Coimbra 2011.

de Visser M., Constitutional Review in Europe. A Comparative Analysis, London 2015.

Garlicki L., “Bezpośrednie stosowanie konstytucji” [in:] Konferencja naukowa: Konstytucja RP w praktyce, Warszawa 1999.

Garlicki L., “Konstytucja a ustawy przedkonstytucyjne” [in:] Wejście w życie nowej Konstytucji Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej. XXXIX Ogólnopolska Konferencja Katedr Prawa Konstytucyjnego, Z. Witkowski (ed.), Toruń 1998.

Gutowski M., Kardas P., Wykładnia i stosowanie prawa w procesie opartym na Konstytucji, Warszawa 2017.

Mikuli P., Zdekoncentrowana sądowa kontrola konstytucyjności prawa. Stany Zjednoczone i pań-stwa europejskie, Kraków 2007.

Radziewicz P., “Judicial Change to the Law-in-Action of Constitutional Review of Statutes in Poland”, Utrecht Law Review 2022, vol. 1.

Radziewicz P., “On legal consequences of judgements of the Polish Constitutional Tribunal passed by an irregular panel”, Review of Comparative Law 2017, vol. 4, issue 31.

Radziewicz P., Tuleja P. (eds), Konstytucyjny spór o granice zmian organizacji i zasad działania Trybunału Konstytucyjnego (czerwiec 2015 – marzec 2016), Warszawa 2017.

Sadurski W., Poland’s Constitutional Breakdown, Oxford 2019.

Ziembiński Z., Problemy podstawowe prawoznawstwa, Warszawa 1980.

Downloads

Published

2022-12-15

How to Cite

Radziewicz, P. (2022). Diffuse Constitutional Review in the Light of Poland’s Constitutional Court Crisis. Gdańsk Legal Studies, (4(56)/2022), 91–98. https://doi.org/10.26881/gsp.2022.4.07

Issue

Section

Glosy i przegląd orzecznictwa