The Theory of Punishment and the Practice of Criminal Justice

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.26881/gsp.2025.4.02

Keywords:

consequentialism, retributivism, sentencing

Abstract

Penal studies in contemporary Poland are dominated by dogmatic analysis. Penology, understood as an interdisciplinary area of research on criminal punishment and other legal and social reactions to acts prohibited under the threat of punishment, does not belong to dynamically developing fields of legal studies. An existing knowledge gap encourages some reflection on the theory of punishment and its impact on practice of criminal justice. Over the centuries, theories of punishment have mainly been debated by philosophers of law. In recent decades, most discussions concerning the theory of punishment have taken place between supporters of consequentialism and retributivism. However, the impact of these discussions on practice is limited. Issues most important to practitioners, such as the question of how much punishment should be imposed on a given offender, are frequently not found to be so important by penal philosophers. Numerous recent reforms of criminal justice systems in the United States and European countries do not fit into any normative framework because they are populist in nature and aim to achieve mainly political goals. As a result, sentencing in the United States is still criticized for being “unprincipled.” In Europe, establishing common sentencing principles for all Council of Europe countries has turned out to be difficult owing to their diverse legal traditions and sentencing practices. More interdisciplinary discussion and research that takes into account both the theoretical and practical problems of punishment are necessary in order to ensure an appropriate normative framework for criminal justice systems.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Ashworth A., Towards European Sentencing Standards, European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research 1994, no. 2(1), pp. 7–11.

Duff R.A., Penal Communications: Recent Work in the Philosophy of Punishment, Crime and Justice 1996, no. 20, pp. 1–97.

Duus-Otterström G., Why Retributivists Should Endorse Leniency in Punishment, Law and Philosophy 2013, no. 32(4), pp. 459–483.

Frase R.S., Limiting Retributivism [in:] The Future of Imprisonment, ed. M. Tonry, New York–Oxford 2004, pp. 83–119.

Grasso A., Broken Beyond Repair: Rehabilitative Penology and American Political Development, Political Research Quarterly 2017, no. 70(2), pp. 394–407.

von Hirsch A., Doing Justice: The Principle of Commensurate Deserts [in:] Sentencing, eds. H. Gross, A. von Hirsch, New York–Oxford 1981, pp. 243–256.

von Hirsch A., Penal Theories [in:] The Handbook of Crime and Punishment, ed. M. Tonry, New York–Oxford 1998, pp. 659–682.

von Hirsch A., Proportionality in the Philosophy of Punishment, Crime and Justice 1992, no. 16, pp. 55–98.

Janicka D., Kodeks Makarewicza w opiniach niemieckich autorów [in:] Nil nisi veritas. Księga dedykowana Profesorowi Jackowi Matuszewskiemu, eds. M. Głuszak, D. Wiśniewska-Jóźwiak, Łódź 2016, pp. 501–516.

Janicka D., O pionierach nauk kryminologicznych w Polsce, Czasopismo Prawno-Historyczne 2016, no. 68(1), pp. 29–50.

de Keijser J.W., Roberts J.V., Ryberg J. (eds.), Predictive Sentencing: Normative and Empirical Perspectives, Oxford–Chicago 2019.

Krajewski K., Teorie kryminologiczne a prawo karne, Warszawa 1994.

Królikowski M., Sprawiedliwość karania w społeczeństwach liberalnych. Zasada proporcjonalności, Warszawa 2005.

Lacey N., Pickard H., The Chimera of Proportionality: Institutionalising Limits on Punishment in Contemporary Social and Political Systems, The Modern Law Review 2015, no. 78(2), pp. 216–240.

Lernell L., Podstawowe zagadnienia penologii, Warszawa 1977.

Lernell L., Współczesne zagadnienia polityki kryminalnej. Problemy kryminologiczne i penologiczne, Warszawa 1978.

Martinson R., What Works? – Questions and Answers about Prison Reform, The Public Interest 1974, no. 42, pp. 22–54.

Morris N., Punishment, Desert and Rehabilitation [in:] Sentencing, eds. H. Gross, A. von Hirsch, New York–Oxford 1981, pp. 257–271.

Reitz K.R., Sentencing [in:] The Handbook of Crime and Punishment, ed. M. Tonry, New York–Oxford 1998, pp. 542–562.

Slobogin C., A Defence of Modern Risk-Based Sentencing [in:] Predictive Sentencing: Normative and Empirical Perspectives, eds. J.W. de Keijser, J.V. Roberts, J. Ryberg, Oxford–Chicago 2019, pp. 107–125.

Tonry M., Can Twenty-first Century Punishment Policies Be Justified in Principle [in:] Retributivism Has a Past. Has it a Future?, ed. M. Tonry, New York 2011, pp. 3–29.

Tonry M., Preface [in:] Retributivism Has a Past. Has it a Future?, ed. M. Tonry, New York 2011, pp. vii–ix.

Tonry M., Punishment and Human Dignity: Sentencing Principles for Twenty-First-Century America, Crime and Justice 2018, no. 47, pp. 119–157.

Tyszkiewicz L., Zarys rozwoju kryminologii w Polsce w latach 1945–1969, Ruch Prawniczy, Ekonomiczny i Socjologiczny 1970, no. 32(3), pp. 61–74.

Utrat-Milecki J., Kara. Teoria i kultura penalna. Perspektywa integralnokulturowa, Warszawa 2010.

Utrat-Milecki J., Penologia ogólna. Perspektywa integralnokulturowa, vol. 1–2, Warszawa 2022.

Weigend T., “Neoklassizismus” – ein transatlantisches Missverständnis, Zeitschrift für die gesamte Strafrechtswissenschaft 1982, no. 94(3), pp. 801–814.

Wiak K., Gądzik Z., Zmiany w zakresie warunkowego przedterminowego zwolnienia z odbycia kary w nowelizacji Kodeksu karnego z 7 lipca 2022 r., Probacja 2023, no. 1, pp. 41–60.

Widacki J. (ed.), Od szkoły klasycznej do neoklasycznej w prawie karnym, Kraków 2016.

Wróblewski B., Naukowa racjonalizacja w prawie kryminalnym, Ruch Prawniczy, Ekonomiczny i Socjologiczny 1939, vol. 19, no. 3, pp. 264–273.

Wróblewski B., Penologja. Socjologja kar, vol. 1–2, Wilno 1926.

Downloads

Published

2025-12-15

How to Cite

Stańdo-Kawecka, B. (2025). The Theory of Punishment and the Practice of Criminal Justice . Gdańsk Legal Studies, (4(69)/2025), 25–38. https://doi.org/10.26881/gsp.2025.4.02